‘A Christmas Carol’ gets 2 and a half stars
By Emily Beech

Those more familiar with the ever-pertinent Muppets re-make of this tale may have found the emphasis on Scrooge’s merciless retribution by supernatural spirits unsettling. This sinister aspect was best seen in the appearance of Marley (Edward Cherrie), Scrooge’s deceased ex-business partner. His body language and anguished cries effectively portrayed the character’s ‘incessant torture of remorse’, though it would have had a greater impact had Cherrie delivered more lines to the audience and not with his back to us.
Unfortunately, at other times the production fell short of creating the eerie atmosphere intended. I would suggest that this wasn’t through want of vision, but the effect was lost rather in the execution. The shifting set was simply too ambitious, the manoeuvres requiring a considerable amount of professionalism, experience and resources to realise.
The performance was often unpolished, including a rather unstable entrance from the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, lines being whispered on from offstage and the characters in constant conflict with the swinging and comically hazardous set.
I felt that some of the dramatic features employed were perhaps superfluous and served only to remind the audience that they were watching a play rather than allowing them to become engrossed in the narrative. For example, the snow machine could in theory have created the perfect Christmas scene, but with the sound of the machine akin to that of a lawnmower, it somewhat deflated any potential illusions of a winter wonderland.
The acting from the main cast was generally good and Huband in particular managed to convey Scrooge’s developing character with considerable skill. The opening interchanges between Scrooge and his nephew Fred (Callum Kenny) were a significant highlight of the production, with Huband’s dry and scathing delivery contrasting perfectly with Kenny’s total embodiment of festive cheer.
Huband’s final begging for remorse was convincing and a credit to Dickens’ eloquent writing. However, minor cast members sometimes lacked lustre and their interactions were somewhat disjointed, making the exchanges seem forced and self-conscious.
Olivia Fox was by far the most natural performer and shone as Martha Cratchit. Credit must also be given to those in charge of make-up and costume, especially considering the challenging range of aesthetic demands this play required.
Regrettably, this play didn’t quite present the spookier and darker facets of this classic story, nor did the concluding Christmas message send me off into the night contentedly musing on the goodwill of the festive season.
Photographs: Nicoletta Asciuto
