A Charitable Scandal

By Georgia Gray

V

olunteering has long had a big red circle around it on the gap year student’s “‘to do” list. The possibility of cultural immersion is much greater than simply trekking to a few beaches and having a sunbathe with half of your school year, and perhaps that person from a rival school that you always used to play at hockey (“fancy bumping into you in Koh Phi Phi!”). Along with the warm fuzzy feeling a little selflessness gives, many travellers genuinely enjoy meeting locals, and giving something back to the place which has (hopefully) hosted them so well. Whilst volunteering can surely only be a good thing, inevitably, there are those who will take advantage of it. AG

It’s four o’ clock on a Tuesday afternoon and the smartly-dressed children of Buenos Aires’ elite are being carefully ushered out of their prestigious, state-of-the-art school and into the hands of their chauffeurs, or into buses that will take them to the gated communities in which their custom-built houses sit, surrounded by a sprinkling of swimming pools and four wheel drives.

Welcome to my gap year work placement, arranged (believe it or not) through an organisation for people wishing to ‘provide a vital service where resources are limited’; the vast discrepancy between the premise and the reality speaks for itself.

The organisation’s website is littered with the word ‘volunteer’ and when I questioned their use of the term, I was told that technically we were volunteers, as we were unpaid.

If we’re going to start splitting semantic hairs, then yes, we were volunteers but companies must understand the connotations attached to this word that is thrown around so carelessly.

However naïve the notion might be, to the mind of a young, idealistic adult the word suggests helping those desperately in need.

In all fairness to the company in question, their website has now been carefully reworded to more accurately reflect the reality of the placement, but only after a steady succession of complaints from displeased and disillusioned ‘volunteers’ who felt that alongside being mislead, they were simply not needed.

Volunteerism, also known as voluntourism has boomed in recent years; the chance for people, often students, to give something back to the countries they set out to explore, as they haul their desire to do good alongside their heavy backpacks into the developing world has proved irresistible for many.

But, as the ever-wise Oscar Wilde once said, “Charity creates a multitude of sins,” and sadly, experiences like mine are the norm rather than the exception in the world of the volunteerism industry.

And without a doubt, this is definitely an industry – companies charge what at times can only be described as extortionate amounts to give well-meaning volunteers the opportunity to help a charity.

Did you know you can volunteer with lion cubs in South Africa for two weeks – a snip at just £1399 (flights excluded)!

Charging such high fees can only mean one of two things: either the project has been set up with sole aim of making money, or the volunteers’ presence is a hindrance to the genuine work of the charity, one that needs to be compensated for in some way.

Lately, reports of a more sinister nature have been leaking out of the volunteerism world. Worse than taking advantage of naïve, well-meaning gappers is the exploitation of those the charity purports to help.

Wildlife and conservation projects are notoriously exploitative and expensive, with the notion of feeding orphaned tiger cubs too appealing a novelty or too good a photo opportunity for wealthy Westerners to pass up.

The result of this lucrative industry is many animals needlessly taken from the wild or purposely kept in sub-standard conditions in what is essentially a glorified petting zoo.

Now, reports of similar treatment towards children are emerging. In Cambodia, to take one well-documented example, a rapid spike in the numbers of orphanages and children in care has been fuelled by the booming volunteerism industry.

Many of these children are not orphans at all, but have been rented, bought or stolen from impoverished families, many of whom have been tricked into thinking that a better life awaits their children.

Instead, they are used as a heart-rending tool in an industry built on guilt, pity and misguided generosity, a pawn in the owners’ quest to coerce money from Western wallets.

Although the volunteerism industry shows no signs of slowing down, ultimately scandals such as these may dissuade people from devoting their time and effort to genuine causes.

It falls to potential volunteers to thoroughly research prospective organisations, ensuring that they will be useful and, more importantly, that their well-meaning gesture does more good than harm.