A boycott for human rights

O BAMA ELECTED; GUANTANAMO closed; and Durham students come over all political. Egads, we mutter, must be the winds of change… or perhaps it’s a collective sigh of relief as we wake up to the human rights violations being committed in our names.

The proposed boycott of Israeli goods is not a condemnation of Israel, but a condemnation of human rights violations in any form. We stand up for ourselves, for all members of our DSU community, in standing up for others. We do not alienate members of our own community; with the same voice as we declare human rights for Palestinians, we claim human rights for ourselves. We cannot protect our own minority groups – Israel supporters or any others you care to name – if we do not by the same token protect others. That’s how human rights work. We affirm, not fracture, our community, thus it must be with the institutional voice of the DSU that we speak. If we cannot stand up for our most basic shared belief, what is the purpose of our student union?

The economic grounds for the boycott come as Israel is party to a Preferential Trade Agreement with Europe by which Israel pays nil or reduced duties on their exports, including those to Britain. Article 2 of this agreement states that these relations rest on respect for human rights; an article most obviously violated in recent weeks in the use of white phosphorous on civilian populations (illegal under the Geneva Convention) and refusing medical aid to Gazans imprisoned in their own territory. Thus all Israeli goods stocked by the DSU cannot but partake in condoning this violation of internationally agreed human rights. In purchasing these goods, we unawares put our name to Israel’s recent barbarism.

Labelling practise finds goods from both Israel and illegal Israeli West Bank settlements labelled as “product of Israel,” thus it is impossible to tell which are legal goods and which fund the greatest obstacle to the peace process, violating human rights under the Forth Geneva Convention (prohibiting transfer of population into occupied territory) and the Hague Regulations (prohibiting permanent change to occupied territory). Israeli organisation Gush Shalom – “Peace Bloc” – states: A penny to the settlements is a penny against peace. Without more stringent labelling, it is impossible for a discerning customer to make an informed decision about what they purchase; this is another change the boycott hopes to elicit.

Furthermore, a boycott is a completely peaceful means of having a tangible effect on a trade-dependant country, with alternatives of petitions and protests utterly unrealistic. These require our government to act on our behalf in pressuring Israel to behave responsibly, the unlikelihood of which is a cautionary lesson we have surely learnt from Iraq, tuition fees and the expansion of Heathrow.

The boycott does not target Israelis themselves, but pressurises the Israeli government to end its flagrant disregard for the international community – for example, the recent bombings of UN compounds in which the IDF had instructed Palestinians to seek shelter. Individual Israelis would benefit from the establishment of an independent Palestinian state in that it would end both the terror attacks and the parasitic economic situation bred by the Occupation. It is for this reason too that arguments that the boycott should harm the very group it seeks to protect, i.e. the Palestinians, fail; should Israel make good on its Oslo Accords pledges, the resolution is beneficial to both parties. Until then, any action taken will impinge upon both parties equally; and recent weeks have taught us that we must take action.

A boycott does not seek to alienate Israel, nor close dialogue. Nor is it permanent; the boycott proposed to the DSU contains a clause for frequent reconsideration as the situation develops. Decades of patronising treatment by the international community by which Israel can violate international law with no repercussions must end, and we show our respect for Israel by expecting it to behave like a grown up.

We condemn human rights violations by Hamas. We condemn human rights violations by Israel. We cannot allow the dismantling of the Geneva Convention; in the words of former Knesset (Israeli parliament) member Uri Avnery, “This war is a crime against ourselves too.” This is not taking sides with one group or another, but taking the only side there can be; that of humanity, in a pro-active affirmation of both our global and local communities. This is a boycott for peace.