20s short story

By Francesca McDowell Finn

There’s a woman in the bar and she’s pretending it’s the 1920s. Hair curled tight against her forehead, gelled solid. Black headband with a single feather. Long black gloves. Short silky dress decorated with thousands of tiny jet beads. Her ears drip gemstones and her neck is strung with pearls that bounce every time she sways to the music. 

She looks every bit the modern flapper girl, wearing the skin of a bygone era.

She orders a drink from the bar, flicking her fingers at the bartender. She’s there with her friends and they crowd around her, the rapid buzz of their conversation rising above the low murmur of the crowd. I can’t hear what they’re saying, but I sense undertones of elation. The others aren’t dressed like flapper girls. The woman receives her drink and it sloshes as she turns, droplets falling through the air like diamonds.

The bar isn’t a speakeasy, but it’s trying to be. Brown, plasticy booths line the walls with tables to put your drinks on. The lights are dim, dim enough that I have to squint to make out the pictures that hang on the green-panelled walls. The whole place has an air of secrecy and exclusivity. But alcohol isn’t illegal anymore, and anyway, it never was in the UK. The front of the venue is a giveaway, too: grey, blocky. Styled like a run-down factory. It’s not decrepit if it’s on purpose. It felt incongruous to the street it was on, a sore thumb, a relic sandwiched between a quaint little café and a Nando’s. Incongruous to the harsh reality of the century we’re living in. All of it –  the subdued atmosphere of the inner bubble against the static roar of the modern day, always fast, always loud, always violently and digitally bright. 

“All of it –  the subdued atmosphere of the inner bubble against the static roar of the modern day, always fast, always loud, always violently and digitally bright.”

The pretzels are a giveaway as well. Literally. They’re free. You’re meant to take one as you come in. Whether I’d taken one or not is between me and God. The woman’s drink is a pale yellow, the glass decorated with blue and yellow flowers curled around the side. I admit that the glass is beautiful. I wonder if women in the 1920s had to cover their drinks with their hands the way this one is.

It’s not the 1920s. The woman’s face is covered in concealer, blush, contour. Her eyes are perfectly shaped and her lipstick is red. It’s so blatantly out of place it almost makes me feel uncomfortable. The rest of her outfit is so perfect, but I can tell from one glance at her sparkly eyeshadow that it’s nothing more than a performance. People always forget to get the makeup right. The 1920s had only just stopped using lead.

No amount of dress-up will tell us what living in a different time is truly like. People like to pretend, anything to get out of the world that they’re living in now. But the truth is, the world we’re living in now is the only one we’ve got. It’s the only one we can understand. The present is our home, and the past is a place that is strange and alien.

We can only ever look at the past through this lens of what we know in the present. It twists the way things were like a funhouse mirror, warping the truth into an idealised version of what might have happened. Remembering only the best parts and calling them the good old days. Forget that you might die of polio, look at the pretty dresses! 

Who does she think she is? I begin to think to myself.

But then the woman in the bar spins, and for a split second, a vision flashes before my eyes. I’m looking into the 1920s, the real one this time. There’s a woman there and she’s with her friends. They’ve had a few drinks and they’re going to be dancing soon. The light from the candles reflects off her beads and tassels in a way that is mesmerising.

With a jolt, I am pulled back to the present. The candles are gone, replaced with strobe lights and fluorescents. But the sparkle of the woman in the bar’s dress as she moves her hips feels awfully familiar. And I realise that even across centuries, across borders unimaginably impenetrable, these two women are connected and illuminated by their shared experience. We can’t ever fully understand what it’s like to live in a different time. But we can understand what it feels like to dance.

I don’t believe in spirits, so I chalk it down to an overactive imagination. But that doesn’t change the fact I feel like I’ve uncovered some sort of primordial truth.

And outside there may be violence and suffering, but here, inside the bar, they have the same laugh.

Image: Konstantin Aal via Unsplash