£1bn “black hole” in new tuition fee regime

By James Ablett

The debate surrounding the coalition’s university fees policy has been reignited following a damning investigation.

The Higher Education Policy Institute (HEPI), a renowned think-tank, probed the validity of the new tuition regime and concluded that it may result in a higher cost to taxpayers than the old system.

A £1bn-a-year “black hole” exists in the policy’s framework, the HEPI announced.

Due to “highly uncertain and optimistic assumptions” on funding, there were miscalculations in the cost of the higher education reforms.

The government has “seriously understated” the full expense of not just implementing the changes, but also the effect these changes will have in the future.

The understatement was summarised by the National Union of Students (NUS).

“The coalition got their sums badly wrong and have left a mess that will take years to fix,” the NUS president Liam Burns said.

The “highly uncertain and optimistic assumptions” on funding were found in two fundamental areas, the report outlined.

Civil servants drafting the new fee guidelines assumed that the average fee charged by universities would be £7,500 a year.

The actual figure is nearer to £8,300, forcing students to borrow more than predicted.

The second assumption was that the average male graduate would be earning £75,000 a year after 30 years (the period by which loans have to be repaid), a figure that had already been revised down from £100,000.

“The coalition got their sums badly wrong and have left a mess that will take years to fix”

This has led the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills to estimate that the shortfall in loans recovery will be around 32 per cent.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies suggests it is nearer to 37 per cent.  These figures indicate the potential for serious loss of government capital.

Using even the most hopeful estimates of loan recovery, the increased cost will be more than £1bn a year, the report declared. They wrote that “this sort of cost would very largely eliminate the savings that the government claims its policies will generate of £1.3bn a year.

“A slightly higher [repayments] cost or a slightly greater inflationary effect than the most optimistic that we have considered here would mean that the present policy is actually more expensive than the one it has replaced.”

Durham was part of the wave of institutions to boost their fees to the uppermost level.

In the last edition, Palatinate highlighted the recent National Student Survey statistics that showed large inconsistencies in student satisfaction across the courses on offer.

The discrepancy in satisfaction raises questions about exactly what the current intake of students will be getting for their £9,000. The trebling of tuition fees in winter 2010 was widely criticised at the time, with mass protests held nationally by students and staff alike.

Over 500 Durham students marched through the city in November of that year to draw attention to the issue. The government held that it was a vital austerity measure in the current economic climate, with Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg sacrificing his reputation by dismissing his pre-election pledge not to support any rise in fees.

The HEPI findings are not just embarrassing for the Liberal Democrats and the government as a whole.

Major doubts have been raised about the coalition’s entire higher education policy, with the opposition government quick to lambast their opponents.

Shabana Mahmood, the Labour Party’s higher education spokeswoman, pointed to “chaos, confusion and incompetence” in the Tory-driven policy.

She added: “Ministers’ justification that fees had to rise has now completely unravelled as experts such as HEPI have shown that the new system will cost taxpayers more.

“This shambolic and out of touch policy has now been exposed as both costly and damaging.”

HEPI’s director, Bahram Bekhradnia, commented on the “serious consequences” of the report.

“Either future taxpayers will need to pay more, other parts of the higher education budget will need to be cut, student numbers will need to be held down even further than presently planned or former students will have to repay more,” he said.

Photograph: flickr