“Women don’t understand fracking”

By Jennifer Hack

Frack (CREDO.fraking via Flickr)

“Women don’t understand fracking,” said a woman. Specifically, it was Averil MacDonald, a professor in science engagement at Reading University and chair of UK Onshore Oil and Gas, who said women “know that they don’t know and they don’t understand [fracking]”. A recent survey carried out by YouGov and University of Nottingham found that only 31.5% of women believe that fracking is a good idea, as opposed to 58% of men. Professor MacDonald attributed part of this mistrust from women to the fact that many stopped studying science at 16.

As a female scientist, this statement somewhat riled me up. I must admit that I’ve been ambivalent in my stance on fracking thus far; I haven’t made an effort to understand the process or the issues surrounding it. But reading what MacDonald had to say about women and fracking (and perhaps this was exactly MacDonald’s intention) spurred me on to find out the facts for myself. I invite any person, male or female, to correct me if I’m wrong.

Fracking (or “hydraulic fracturing”) is used to access the abundant oil and gas that is trapped in shale rocks in the Earth’s crust. It involves drilling vertically down into the shale rock, which is full of tiny cracks where oil and gas are trapped. Upon reaching the shale, the pipe is bent at a 90° angle and drilling proceeds horizontally for several miles to give access to a large amount of rock. Next, a mixture of water, so-called ‘slickwater’, sand and chemicals is pumped at high pressure through the pipe into the rock, which causes the tiny fissures in the rock to spread apart. The sand serves to hold the cracks open and allows for the release of gas and oil, which can then be flushed out to the surface.

So the process is relatively simple, but why are people so concerned? Firstly, pumping chemicals into the ground increases the risk of contaminating the drinking water supply, and the process has also caused minor earthquakes. Another concern is whether removing vast quantities of oil and gas will have an effect on the geology of the Earth. A final argument against fracking is that it is not a long-term solution to our increasing energy demand. Oil and gas are fossil fuels, and energy is required for transporting and pressurising large volumes of water. Given the many potential problems with fracking, it’s easy to see why anyone, regardless of gender, might remain sceptical. But as with any argument, there is another side.

It’s easy to see why anyone, regardless of gender, might remain sceptical

Oil and gas are ‘cleaner’ sources of energy than coal, and have fewer associated emissions. In addition, more fuel means a more secure energy supply. This lowers energy prices, which alleviates the pressures of cash-strapped Brits, and allows us to deal with the increasing demand of a growing population that is increasingly dependent on electricity. Finally, having access to a local supply of oil and gas means that we don’t have to buy it in from abroad; we reduce our reliance on other countries and provide oil and gas at fair and affordable prices.

In light of all I have discovered about fracking, I will join the 31.5 % of women with concerns, although I think MacDonald and the polls are wrong to try to justify and quantify the different stances of men and women. We all need educating about fracking and we cannot get het-up with such unhelpful statistics. Surely it is better to invest our research efforts into actually finding out what concerns people have and then providing the answers?

My biggest worry is the uncertainty of how drilling will affect the Earth’s structure, and the potential danger to UK towns. I do see fracking as a positive short-term solution, but if we are to create a sustainable energy landscape for future generations, we must invest in more reliable alternatives. Nuclear is one option, but that’s a whole new debate.

Photograph: CREDO.fracking via Flickr