“Probably the best student representative system of any university in the country”

Durham

by Sally Wardle

Durham University Vice-Chancellor Chris Higgins has defended the University’s handling of 38 week lets, college allocations and implementation of the living wage in an interview with Purple Radio’s Alex Morgan.

The interview, broadcast on 7th March, saw the Vice-Chancellor and Pro-Vice Chancellor Tom Ward questioned on issues decided by listeners.

In the interview, the Vice-Chancellor reacted to the recent controversy surrounding changes to the college allocation policy.

The changes mean that once accepted to the University, students should be assigned to their first choice college.

However, if the college is oversubscribed for a particular subject quota, students will be randomly selected and unsuccessful students being randomly allocated to an alternative college.

There has been heated reaction to the changes, including petitions from both Chad’s and University College.

However, in the interview with Purple Radio, Chris Higgins argued “false rumours [and] false myths have perhaps led opposition.”

He added, “the vote in Chad’s was not on the right motion anyway because they’d been presented with a system which wasn’t the system that was being introduced. Hopefully their college Principal will talk to them and give them the real story.”

However, an anonymous JCR member, who contacted Palatinate, stated “there is a good flow of information in Chad’s from both the Principal and the Senior Man.”

The source also attached an email sent from Senior Man Tom Bishop to Chad’s JCR on 23rd February, in which Senior Man Tom Bishop reflects upon the Vice-Chancellor’s reply to their petition.

The email states: ‘It is our firm belief that they have Durham’s best interests at heart.

‘However we believe their methods to be both flawed and detrimental to the collegiate system.’

It continues, ‘We would however question the Vice-Chancellor’s assertion that College Heads “singly and collectively, developed and implemented the new processes,” for our understanding of the process gives an entirely different narrative of events.’

In his reply to the petition, the Vice-Chancellor had stated there would be a meeting ‘to have a general discussion of the issue with any interested students as soon as a date can be found.’

In reference to this, Tom Bishop responded, ‘We don’t want another meeting to explain the policy. We want to question the policy at a level where our questioning can really matter.’

During the Purple Radio interview, the Vice-Chancellor responded to claims over a lack of student consultation in the college allocations policy change:

“There are specific miscommunications which may have happened in one or two of the colleges, but the general consultation and input from students has been phenomenal.”

However, this contradicts a statement in the email sent to Chad’s JCR, in which Tom Bishop comments: ‘We see things very differently. Student consultation simply did not occur.

‘Student representatives were informed about the policy late in the day, but they were certainly never consulted during the development of the new policy.’

Alex Morgan, of Purple Radio, pushed the issue of student consultation with the Vice-Chancellor during his interview.

Chris Higgins argued that Durham has “probably the best student representative system of any University in the country.”

However, some Purple Radio listeners rejected these claims in messages to the studio during the broadcast.

We have a good representative system but it isn’t deployed

One commented: ‘We have a good representative system but it isn’t deployed/ used by the University.’

Another listener added: ‘We might have access to communication but often people are told to ‘keep quiet’ about issues.’

38 week lets were raised in the interview as an example of a lack of consultation between the University and students.

The Vice-Chancellor responded: “There is no purpose in going backwards and looking at the details of something which has already been implemented.”

Some students assert that enforced 38 week lets at college accommodation mean students no longer have the ability to opt in or out of the agreement, as was the case previously, removing an element of student choice.

However, Chris Higgins stated “There is much greater choice actually,” and argued as some colleges do not have 38 week lets applicants can apply to a college which suits their needs.

He added “Of course it doesn’t mean choice for the students who are in college already.”

Comments made by the Vice-Chancellor concerning the Living Wage Campaign have also been subject to scrutiny.

The Living Wage campaign is attempting to implement the ‘living-wage’ of £7.45 per hour for all staff at the University, a figure which is calculated by looking at the basic cost of living, describing the minimum hourly wage necessary for an individual to meet daily needs.

FOI figures from 2011 show that at Durham University, more than one in eight members of staff were paid less than the Living Wage.

In his interview, Chris Higgins suggested the University “haven’t had any representation for DSU” but admitted that “there are certainly students out there who think this might be an issue.”

He continued, “it is not clear to me that actually this is a necessary and important concern. If it is then the students really ought to raise it through the DSU”

However Stuart Armstrong, Durham University Labour Club Living Wage Officer and Jim Elliot, DSU Societies and Student Development Officer, attended a meeting with Human resources this term with Mrs Joanne Race, Deputy Director of Human Resources and Mrs Susanne Bradley, Rewards Manager at Durham University to discuss the implementation of the Living Wage, a claim backed by those involved.

Students have reacted forcefully to the Purple Radio interview and in particular the discrepancies in some of the Vice-Chancellor’s comments.

One stated: “Nothing about this seems black or white. Sensible examination of the claims made to students seems like the way forward from here.”

Another stated, “While it was a fruitful conversation, what did alarm me was the apparent discrepancy between much of what the Vice Chancellor was saying, and what I had heard from sources both in the student body and among the staff.

“It would be interesting to now follow up the claims made to try and get at the truth.”

[poll id=”11″]

Photograph: Emma Werner