“Oh Romeo, Romeo! Wherefore art thou Romeo?”

Every year on Valentine’s Day, single girls up and down the country vow that they will change their lives in the next year. Single no more, they think, I will find love! It’s a depressing state of affairs. Forget all that ‘single-and-loving-it!” nonsense; almost everyone wants to be struck by Cupid. Bored of waiting to be swept off their feet, our three intrepid reporters have taken matters into their own hands and gone ‘alternative’ dating; online, blind and locally. Finding a man’s easy, right? Bottles of wine consumed – 7, official dates attended – 2, hours spent online – innumerable, locals hit on – 6, boyfriends – 0. Damn.
The Online Dater – Maz Farookhi

It might be hard to believe, but despite being a long-term singleton, I’ve never viewed Valentine’s day with either much enthusiasm or disgust – as far as I’m concerned it’s just another excuse for a themed formal and the traditional copious amounts of alcohol that go with it.

But when my friend proposed what can only be described as a ‘dating experiment’, I seemed to be volunteered as a guinea-pig for the job before I’d finished my drink. Of course, mention online dating to most people, particularly of our age, and you can predict what the response will be. But, good friend that I am and in the name of investigative journalism, I took up the offer and decided to meet the challenge head-on.

My problem was I had no clue how to start. I didn’t have much experience with anything like this, but I knew for sure I didn’t just want to upload some photos of me taken in flattering light with a camera lens covered in Vaseline and hope that the offers would flood in. Instead, I decided to log onto the Guardian Online’s ‘Soulmates’ and see if I could find any success; as my mother so excitedly pointed out, people of a certain ‘type’ would be enlisting the services of the Guardian.

I knew instantly I wouldn’t be able to fill out my profile on my own. Sitting by yourself in a college room attempting to be witty just isn’t a good idea; you’ll come across like you’re trying too hard. I had to enlist help. This is where my first tip comes in: if any of you decide to take up the online dating challenge, get your friends to fill in your profile for you. It makes it a lot easier, and makes for hilarious reading when you see how they describe you in your profile – ‘drinking habits: excessive’. Thanks, girls.

Whilst trying to work out a witty, yet succinct username, I realised that this really wasn’t that different from filling in a Facebook profile. Describing myself as ‘very attractive’ was a personal highlight, and I just had to hope that my ‘struggling’ annual income would be overshadowed by a cheeky tagline. By the time I’d filled in the details about my ideal date (‘Attending a sporting event’), I realised I sounded like a complete bloke and maybe this was why I’d been single all this time. But I’ve never laughed so much in my life.

Categories with options to describe myself such as ‘Sense of Humour: I don’t have one / puerile’, ‘What best describes your fashion sense?: Clothes strictly optional’ and ‘How do your friends rate your intelligence?: Intellectually challenged’ had us crying, we were laughing so hard. And this is when I concluded a second thing about online dating tactics: don’t take yourself too seriously. Nobody else will. But this was never going to be an issue once we’d uploaded my profile picture – fancy dress of the 118 man with a drawn on moustache. We sat back and waited.

Not for long. Urged on by the endorphin-fuelled high we found ourselves experiencing, we’d ticked pretty much no preference for all the categories for potential partners. So I had no preference for age, occupation, annual income, appearance, body type, education or drinking and smoking habits. I drew the line at ticking the ‘4’7” or shorter’ box though. Investigating the profiles that the website had decided were my ideal matches, it therefore came as no shock to find nearly everyone was an 84% or higher compatible match. Cue further hoots of laughter at certain profiles (“Well, hello ladies – hope you’re having fun on here?”’), until we actually found a bit of a looker.

‘Steve’ certainly seemed to have a lot going for him; 22 years old, pictures of him skiing and with small children and pets, he seemed to tick all the boxes. But there was still a nagging feeling that I just couldn’t shift. What’s wrong with him? There must be something or he wouldn’t be signed up to this website. Maybe he’s got a third nipple? Or worse? But we took the plunge and added him to My Favourites. Before the bizarre situation of effectively poking a random from Chester hit me, the emails started to roll in. ‘You have a new fan!’ was waiting in my inbox, only a few minutes after we’d set up the profile.

Any grand ideas I had about being checked out by some single, good-looking twenty-somethings definitely came crashing back down to earth when we viewed this ‘fan’s’ profile. A few seconds later and a box flashed up on the screen. ‘Someone at Guardian Soulmates wants to chat online to you!’ We loaded up the profile cautiously. I think the best description that can be given was from my friend; “Oh my God, he looks like a Bo Selecta character!” Brilliant. Where were the Steves, rather than the ‘Well endowed (intellectually)’ and ‘dirty filthy stuntman/drag queen’?

The next day I woke up and, not without a slight feeling of trepidation, checked my email account. Fourteen emails from Soulmates. Right. Logging into my dating account, I checked out my potential list of suitors who had become a ‘fan’ and viewed my profile overnight. Not really a surprise, when you consider the kind of people who’d be up at 3am on an online dating website. But I spent the rest of the day constantly checking my profile, just like the time I first joined Facebook and realised what a brilliant procrastination technique that was. And then the real excitement: ‘The interest is mutual!!!’ Seeing that many exclamation marks pop up in my inbox definitely made this something to investigate. Apparently Steve had had a perusal of my profile and decided to become my fan as well.

So then there was the problem of getting in contact. I suddenly realised the flaw with online dating. It’s all very well surfing the online scene, clicking quickly on different faces and names that take our fancy, but at the end of it all, there’s still the same sudden rush of anxiety when you realize someone has to make the first move. The same issues I have in the real world are present in the virtual one. No wonder I felt that everything seemed to have been careering along so swimmingly before.

I enlisted the help of some male friends. I saw on Steve’s profile that he seemed to be based in Wales because of work, and so after a particularly heavy night out, I mentioned to one of my male Welsh friends that I’d set up the profile for an article and a bit of a joke, but had suddenly found myself wondering how to approach someone who was potentially not a weirdo. We went online and wrote a suitably witty yet heartfelt and sensitive message, something along the lines of asking him whether he lived near that place with the really long name (I got my friend to type that bit).

At the same time, I had no problem messaging back some of the other men who seemed a little more eccentric than I was used to. I was intrigued by some of their techniques – online dating definitely has the same cheesy chat-up lines, although they do come in a slightly different form. I got used to seeing ‘I don’t normally message people like this, but you’ve really caught my eye’ and numerous others countless times, plus everyone claimed to be running their own ‘company’. Really? All of you? Possibly a little lean with the truth in that department then.

I arranged to meet up with one guy for coffee. It was one of the most awkward experiences of my life. I’d met up with this one purely because he lived in Durham and my deadline was quickly approaching, so I needed to go on an actual date and have face-to-face contact with one of the people I’d met over the internet. Our complete lack of any common interests was apparent from the off. I tried my fail-safe tactic that I always use in awkward social circumstances and talked as much about sport as I could – perhaps the look of horror on my face when he professed that he’d never sat through a whole football match and didn’t know that the Six Nations was an international rugby tournament was the catalyst to our hastily made excuses and hurried exit.

I’ve been asked a few times if I’ll close down my profile now that I’ve finished the research and written the article. I can safely say that I’ll be keeping it open; despite the number of goons you’ve got to go through to find one that looks half decent, it’s easier to contact and chat to a lot more people by using online dating. Which brings me back to Steve. Despite my friend’s thoughts that he ‘seems too good to be true’, we have been messaging each other and he doesn’t seem like a psycho – for this reason alone I’ll be checking my profile regularly. Maybe it’s not as easy as they say (‘you’re guaranteed to click with whoever you meet’), but there’s potential.

The Local Dater – Emily Purser

Okay, so to begin with, I’m going to accept the blame: this whole thing was my idea. Valentine’s Day is approaching, I’m single and I thought it would be funny to try and rectify the situation before the 14th arrived and I found myself having supper with other single girls. Not that I don’t love doing that, but for one day of the year, just one, it might be nice to throw out the cynicism and embrace all that lovey dovey stuff and have a romantic Valentine’s. That was the plan- but how to make it happen?

I managed to cajole a couple of my single friends into the experiment. Meeting guys through friends, nights out or sports teams like a normal person clearly wasn’t working for us, so we had to go about it another way. We laid our ideas on the drawing board and assigned tactics. Maz was deemed ‘street’ enough to take on the mysterious online dating world, Clare would surely make the best first impression on a blind date, and i could only be tolerated for a few minutes at a time, so would go speed dating.

Meet problem Number One: apparently, speed dating in the Newcastle/Durham area is a discriminating sport and won’t have you unless you’re 25. I’m not. We talked about pretending to be older, but I would have had to come up with a whole host of lies about why I was still up north to get away with it. Plus, I wasn’t that keen on spending even three minutes with some sleazy 55-year-old.

So, I wanted to find a guy who was out of the University bubble, but without being forced to chat to dates my father’s age and adding five years to my age. We decided to go dating locally- in other words, hit North Road on a Friday night.

When i first told my friends about this idea, they called my stupid. I was going for brave. The Friday before, I had wound up in one of North Road’s hotspots (don’t ask why) and had been having a great time until a girl called us over and said, menacingly. “You see that smashed bottle right there?”, “Yeah”, “I just threw that at you”. Right. A quick exit followed.

So, going back to the scene of the crime wasn’t necessarily a great idea, but I was determined to see this through and potentially find a guy to take me to supper on Thursday. We went out for a meal beforehand and had a few bottles of wine, for Dutch courage. First stop: the Fighting Cocks.

Now we all know about the Fighting Cock’s reputation. Forget all that Student Night stuff- it’s a local joint. We entered to the suspicious looks of the bouncers and found it absolutely packed, with ‘Take Me Home, Country Roads’ bleating out on the sound systmem. All over the place, heads turned as we realised we were a good 15 years younger than any of the other people in there. Undettered, we headed for the bar and ordered more stiff drinks. Even the barman- the best looking guy in there- gave us a strange look. Our main admirers were an aging group of men who were clearly on a Lads’ NIght Out. Wives at home – who knows?

Approaching them was a little daunting, and, frankly, stupid, so we turned to the bar instead. We hit on James the Hot Barman, who didn’t seem impressed. This wasn’t going well. We decided to hit the dancefloor in case the men without athritus were there. No luck. It was like the dancefloor of Klute in twenty years time; packed, sweaty, drinks flying everywhere and no men. This wasn’t going anywhere… time to move on.

We went into Walkabout briefly, but found it much deader than it looks from outside. Across the road into Wetherspoons and it was time to start being proactive. We got drinks and approached a group of young-ish guys with the thinly veiled line, “where’s good to go out around here?”. We got chatting and established they were local professionals, two of whom had been at Durham. Somehow our plan to remain honest flew out the window and we became Durham graduates working in Marketing, based in London and on a night out back up north. Thinking on my feet, I suddenly lived in Dulwich -why?- and left Cuths four years ago. One of the guys told me he had also been in Cuths and was about to launch into a do-you-know-….so I ran to the loo. On my return, I asked the guys, who were in suits, why they were so dressed up. A quick look at each other, and they announced they had just come from a funeral. Shit. Drunk, and looking to fill the awkward silence, I jumped in with “I’m sorry for your loss”. Oops.

Conversation descended into chat about our lives (fake), their children (illegitimate), and our knowledge of Durham (supposedly poor). When I got into discussing familial stability with Gavin, I knew it was time to leave. A fake text appeared on my phone and we suddenly had to go and meet Laura in Varsity. With calls of, “we’ll meet you there!”, we hurried away (to Klute).

It was certainly an entertaining night, if not a fruitful one. The second we lied about our ages and pretty much everthing about our lives, all hopes of finding a date were dashed. We met nice guys, albeit not ones I wanted to see again. Perhaps I’ve learnt my lesson: stick to University boys.

The Blind Dater – Claire Finney

Blind dating? Over my dead body, was my first thought. Yet as Valentine’s Day looms nearer, my initial reaction of absolute horror starts to melt. Red and pink hearts spread over Durham like eczema, PDA sightings reach an all time high (even the sodding ducks are at it), and every shop, from the aptly named LeBeado to the somewhat less alluring Bairstow Eves, bids blissful lovers to ‘give something special’ this year. Suddenly, the idea of any kind of romance looks increasingly appealing – even if it is in the painfully contrived form of a blind date. In fact, next to the local dater and the online dater, I seemed to have a lucky escape; my matchmaker is no cupid, but at least I had a fairly good chance of meeting someone below the age of 45 and childless.

After a week of moderately nervous anticipation, I get the email: ‘After much, MUCH persuasion, I think I’ve found a friend who would be up for taking you on a blind date.’

Much persuasion? I can’t help feeling a tad miffed – until I remember that it is of course a blind date, and for all this elusive ‘friend’ knows I might be obese with questionable facial hair. And of course, the idea of a blind date does conjure up some truly terrifying images: Cilla Black, painful silences followed by that killer blow, ‘Beautiful weather we’re having, isn’t it?’ – well, its a wonder anyone would ever do it.

A traditionalist to the last, I reluctantly pass ‘cupid’ my number and tell him to tell him to text me – I’m determined to retain some scrap of dignity, and first dates are most definitely the guy’s initiative.

That night, I get the text, and almost immediately my keen ‘text-analyser instinct’ starts to kick in… Hi’ – restrained, I prefer ‘Hey’… but then the ‘X’ is capitalised (meaningful) and there’s definite showing of initiative in the suggestion of dinner then Sweeney Todd; although some might say dinner and cinema is verging on keen, not to mention the questionable film choice – blood-spattered haircuts on a first date?

Suddenly aware of what I’m doing, I quickly restrain myself and hit reply. I suggest Fat Buddha, partly because I firmly believe its Pad Thai to be the best thing that’s happened to Durham since the Cathedral, but mainly because of the psychedelic walkway, which would provide at least one talking point if all else failed. I say I’ve seen Sweeney Todd – I haven’t, but I’d hate to look wimpish, even if this whole thing is in the name of journalistic ‘research’.

With noodles now on the agenda, I’m actually starting to get slightly excited. And really, how unrealistic can How to Lose A Guy in 10 Days actually be?

Things take a dramatic turn for the worse when a ‘short’, spontaneous adventure into the countryside for lunch at a friend’s melts into hours and hours of feasting and flumping. After champagne, Yorkshire puddings, fruit pie and Notting Hill, none of us could remember quite why we wanted to go back to the bubble; the ‘Big Date’ didn’t even enter my head.

That is, until the train home. Halfway between Newcastle and Durham, I realise there is absolutely no way I’m going to have time to get ready – and after a good doze, a bone-rattling car journey and a mad and sweaty dash for the train I dread to think what I look like; even running straight from the station I’d probably be too late to be fashionable. Things hit an all time low when my desperate attempts to hastily touch up my make up in the train toilet prove futile when I remember that the only beauty product I have with me is Vaseline, and that I’m still dressed for that country walk (which had been abandoned somewhere between the dinner table and the sofa).

I arrived at Fat Buddha very late, panting, with rainy, windswept hair, panda eyes and very shiny lips; I can’t say it was love at first sight on my part but then I somewhat suspect the feeling was mutual. The awkwardness was surprisingly brief, and once we’d overcome our collegiate prejudices (‘Hatfield?’ ‘St. John’s?!’) the conversation was pleasant; but I think we both felt somewhat bemused. There was no drunken night to laugh over or mutual tutors to moan about, and no instinctive chemistry to remind us why we were out together. Love may very well be blind, but I remain to be convinced that dating should be.