“I have nothing to say” – Are Managers and Players Right to Shun Media Duties?

Of course, I use the term ‘managers’ quite broadly. And of course, the focus of this piece inevitably has to be on one José Mourinho.
The Chelsea manager appears to relish controversy and attention, and my goodness is he doing a good job of generating it this season.
Mourinho currently finds himself under investigation from the Football Association for comments made after Chelsea’s 3-1 home defeat to Southampton. He has also just received a £40,000 fine alongside a stadium ban that will result in the Portuguese being unable to attend his side’s fixture against Stoke City at the Britannia Stadium. The 52-year-old is also the subject of legal action following his treatment of former club doctor Eva Carneiro.
Quite frankly, there is no hiding the fact that Mourinho is making the work of many journalists all too easy right now. Whilst creating headlines is no mean feat for many, for Mourinho it has become a recurring theme; a predictability every Saturday evening.
However, as a supporter of football and sport as a whole, I am sure that I’m not alone in saying I have had enough of those in the spotlight quite consciously avoiding media responsibilities.
Speaking to BT Sport after Chelsea’s latest setback – a 3-1 loss to rivals Liverpool at Stamford Bridge – Harry Redknapp spoke quite excellently in front of the watching audience about what should be expected from Premier League managers when speaking to the media.
The former Tottenham, Bournemouth and QPR manager responded to Mourinho’s now infamous ‘I have nothing to say’ interview by stressing that all managers are disappointed after defeat and that “you have to be gracious in victory… and gracious [in defeat]”.
Redknapp’s comments had earlier been echoed by former Liverpool star Steve McManaman, who emphasised the thoughts of so many supporters by stating that not “once has he said my team wasn’t good enough”. Surely this was all the interview required?
It is important to stress at this stage that the Chelsea manager is not the only elite sporting individual who has given the cold shoulder to a question relating to a bit of gossip within the club.
Another Premier League manager who has also endured his fair share of undesirable headlines is Crystal Palace manager Alan Pardew. And just like Mourinho, Pardew has also been criticised by fans and pundits alike for shunning media duties in the past.
One example that comes to mind was following his former club Newcastle’s 3-2 victory over Everton just days before leaving the North East club to join Palace. Pardew left the interview to his assistant at the time, John Carver, and many questioned whether this was a justifiable action.
A more recent example of where a sporting individual has come under scrutiny for their attitude towards the media involved Harlequins and England full-back Mike Brown after his nation’s defeat to Wales during the recently concluded Rugby World Cup.
For some, Brown’s responses embodied the regret of a nation and showed just how much the defeat hurt. To others, the interview was quite evidently disrespectful, with the England star purposely making life difficult for the interviewers as he failed to get over the defeat.
Please do not think that I am targeting these three figures personally. Anyone who plays sport understands just how difficult it can be to accept defeat sometimes. We all play to win. However, one of the responsibilities that comes with being an elite sport star, or a Premier League manager, is that you should address your fans after a match and complete what is, let’s face it, a rather short post-match interview.
Do Mourinho, Pardew and Brown, amongst others, hold the belief that their supporters, who may have travelled the length of the country or flown abroad, spent every spare penny that they have, and held every piece of hope that their side would win, are not just as, if not more, disappointed than they are with a defeat?
The post-match interview is an opportunity for these individuals who are admired by so many, to share joy in the glory that they feel after victory, and likewise show humility in defeat.
So Mourinho et al. Next time that you are a little frustrated after defeat, do not just ignore your responsibility to conduct an interview because you don’t want to answer a question about your tactics and/or mistakes. Hold your head up and speak to those supporters who have given their free time to support you, and suggest where things went wrong and what might change next time around.
Photograph: Bendoni communication via Wikimedia Commons
