“Exam results matter” says report

Studentsworkinginlibrary

by Charlotte Bransgrove

A new report published by the Centre for Economic Performance has found that the class of degree achieved by graduates does have a significant effect on their earnings.

The findings demonstrate that those who leave university having obtained a first or upper second class honours degree can expect higher wages than those who graduate with a lower second or less.

Researchers Andy Feng and Georg Graetz, from the London School of Economics, analysed the exam marks of 2,649 LSE undergraduates between 2005 and 2010 as part of their investigation into the correlation between degree class and graduate earnings.

According to the results of their study, the greatest wage difference emerges between those obtaining a 2:1 rather than a 2:2, who were found to earn 7% more in their first year of employment. This equates to around £2000 a year, which across a forty year period could mean an additional £81,000 for those with upper second degrees, assuming a consistent wage increase.

Moreover, the research found graduates with a first class degree earn around 3% more than those with a 2:1, confirming that not only is the value of a higher class degree recognised by employers, but that this can influence the salary one can expect from graduate employment.

However, the study also showed that women are failing to financially benefit from graduating with a first.

A further breakdown of the 3% average revealed that while men receive a 6% boost in wages compared to those with a 2:1, this is not reflected in the salaries of women, who are failing to gain any increased income.

The researchers seemed unable to explain the financial losses for women, labelling the results “a puzzle,” and suggesting “Perhaps men are more likely to ask for or be given a higher wage offer. We honestly don’t know.”

They also claimed their study was “probably the best evidence available that exam results matter,” demonstrating that degree class thresholds can significantly impact graduate salaries.

Statistics from Durham University Student Planning and Assessment reveal that 84% of graduating students from the University in 2012 achieved a 2:1 or above, suggesting that the vast majority of Durham students can expect to enjoy the financial benefits of obtaining a higher class degree.

Despite this, many undergraduates appear to fear the repercussions of failing to obtain a 2:1 or above at the end of their degree. The stigma attached to a 2:2, often colloquially referred to as a ‘Desmond’, means that an upper second is increasingly considered by students an essential for graduate employment in a highly competitive market.

Kate, a second year mathematician, told Palatinate, “I think I would feel disappointed if I didn’t graduate with a 2:1 or a first, and it would definitely make me worry about my career prospects. Many graduate jobs specify a minimum requirement of an upper second even just to apply.”

The report however, did not investigate the long term effect of degree class on wages, and further research will be required in order to establish whether or not obtaining a higher class degree will continue to financially benefit graduates across their life time careers.

Photograph: Durham University Images