‘Yes Scotland’ campaign lacks political strength

Scottish flag 600 x 400

by Jack Humphries

The ‘Yes Scotland’ campaign website firmly asserts that ‘it is fundamentally better for all of us if decisions about Scotland’s future are taken by the people who care most about Scotland’, by which they mean the Scottish Parliament. I’d argue that this implies a distrustful, almost paranoid opinion of the politicians in Westminster, if it weren’t for the fact that this cynical suspicion is almost a matter of pride for the majority of the UK’s population.

What the Scottish National Party (SNP) are really trying to argue is that decisions about Scotland’s future ought to be made in Edinburgh rather than in London, a point which has been almost constantly contested since the 1707 Treaty of Unity established the current United Kingdom. The question on the referendum ballot paper in 2014 has been finalised at the time of writing and reads: ‘Should Scotland be an independent country?’

Both sides seem to be in the wrong, the current government by refusing to legally outline concrete plans for Scotland and the SNP for pressing for a swift resolution.

Many opponents to the ‘Yes Scotland’ campaign complain that Scotland is too small to gain independence, although when you compare the Scottish population of 5.3 million to the 5.6 million of Denmark or the 5.4 million of Finland, it is difficult to understand why Scotland would not be able to flourish just as well as these wealthy nations. Campaigners cite Scotland’s impressive natural energy reserves as one of the key arguments for the viability of ‘Yes Scotland’, specifically their reserves of North Sea oil and the potential for renewable development in off shore wind and wave technology. Basing your country’s future on rapidly dwindling oil reserves seems to be short sighted in the least, but since an agreement on the split of the North Sea oil tax between the Scottish and UK governments has yet to be reached, any conclusion here would be entirely speculative.

After a turbulent last few years for the euro, the SNP now plan to keep Scotland in the Sterling for the foreseeable future. With the politically divergent momentum of the independence campaign and the loss of any political union between the two countries, maintaining balance in the Sterling could be one of the toughest challenges that the nascent Scottish government may face. One other factor to consider when assessing the fairness of the planned referendum is the 750,000 Scots currently residing in other parts of the UK who will be ineligible to vote on their own country’s future. This equates to more than a tenth again of the Scottish population, a sizable amount of people effectively being forced to accept an entirely new legal citizenship. In addition to this, the questions of pension transferral, defence assets, national debt and an accountability for the tens of billions spent bailing out Scottish banks over the last five years have all yet to be answered by the Yes campaign, let alone agreed upon by Edinburgh and London.

David Cameron has said that he will not ‘pre-negotiate Scotland’s exit from the United Kingdom’, a statement which implies that the Scottish people will be entering into a referendum ‘blind’ as it were, with little or no idea what a settlement would ultimately entail. Cynics here might say that with parties breaking pre-election promises on a regular basis (think coalition on student fees and EMA), it scarcely matters that such issues are not going to be up to the voting public. I hope that I am not alone in believing that acting under such political blindness cannot in any way be called a democracy.

Both sides seem to be in the wrong, the current government by refusing to legally outline concrete plans for Scotland’s future and the SNP for pressing for a swift resolution to the issue when the technical outcomes are currently so undecided. Reports analysing the possible effects of Scottish independence are already being released and will continue to accumulate over the coming months, but without solid political agreement, definitive policies will not be arising. Optimism and a brighter future are the promises made by the Yes Campaign, but these promises seem to be being thrown to a post-referendum wind of confusion, made without considering quite how Westminster will treat the Scottish in the event of a Yes vote. Courtesy to Jeremy Warner for summing up Alex Salmond’s slightly naïve position on this: ‘You keep all the national debt, we keep all the oil’.

The SNP must be all too aware that they will be unable to deliver on many of their proposals whilst entering into such a referendum without a prior, legally binding, agreement with the country that they will be seceding from. Deceiving a country’s worth of people in such a way is not just irresponsible, but reprehensible, and in no such way reflects the actions of a party of people ‘who care most about Scotland’. They may not be being ‘bought and sold for English gold’ this time, but the Scottish people should perhaps be mindful of the same old ‘parcel of rogues’ in their own parliament.