We Need a New National Union of Students – A National Union for All Students

By Sam Bentwood

As has been well publicised, last Wednesday the National Union of Students ‘elected’ a new president. I use inverted commas because when I say elected I mean appointed by the NUS delegates present at their conference, not directly by the whole student population. Interestingly, a One Member One Vote motion that proposed it might be more democratic to allow all of NUS’ members – that’s us – a direct say in who should be the President and Vice Presidents of our union was overwhelmingly rejected. But anyway, it is fair to say this new presidential appointment has generated a reasonable amount of controversy, much of which results from several past statements made by Ms Bouattia that have been interpreted by many has having distinctly anti-Semitic overtones. Comments such as describing the University of Birmingham as ‘something of a Zionist outpost’, suggesting the government’s contested Prevent strategy is fuelled by ‘all manner of Zionist and neo-con lobbies’ and condemning ‘Zionist-led media outlets’ meant that no fewer than 47 presidents of Jewish societies across the country felt compelled to pen an open letter to Ms Bouattia expressing their concerns. A video even emerged the day before our new president was appointed in which she stressed her belief that peaceful resistance to the Israeli occupation was not enough in itself, insisting that it must be coupled with violent resistance in order to be successful, even if such resistance is presently classified as terrorism because, in her view, future generations will view it differently. For anyone looking to defend her on this one: no, I’m afraid she didn’t even qualify her incitements with any suggestion that ‘resistance’ should be limited to military targets. I wonder if that means the bombing of a bus in Jerusalem last Monday would be a part of the ‘resistance’ she called for?

Now, before we go any further, something needs to be made clear. Obviously there is a clear distinction between criticising policies of Israeli governments and being anti-Semitic – one is completely legitimate, one is absolutely not. Now, despite the attempted corruption of the word ‘Zionist’ by those who oppose Israel to mean something along the lines of ‘Israeli extremist opposed to Palestinian human rights’, the word actually means someone who supports the existence of a Jewish homeland within what was the historical land of Israel – that’s within, not over the entirety of. Having served as NUS’ Black Students’ Officer I assume Ms Bouattia knows that Dr Martin Luther King was himself a Zionist? It is perfectly possible to be a Zionist critic of the Israeli government, who advocates for the rights of Palestinians and believes in a two-state solution. Through these statements Ms Bouattia – ignorantly or otherwise (though you would expect someone who has testified to the United Nations to make sure they understand the meaning of the words they use) – is not only furthering the false and malicious portrayal of the Zionist movement but furthering age-old conspiracy theories about Jewish desires for world domination. Dr King indeed once wrote ‘When people criticise Zionism, they mean Jews – make no mistake about it’, and Maajid Nawaz, the counter-extremist and founding chairman of the Quilliam Foundation, described her speech on ‘resistance’ as ‘chilling’. In her defence, she has insisted she is not anti-Semitic (at the same time as implying her critics were potentially guilty of Islamophobia for daring to request clarification of her views), has re-iterated her determination to tackle all forms of prejudice and voted in favour of continuing to commemorate Holocaust Memorial Day – because yes, some NUS delegates apparently believed that we should stop commemorating the Holocaust.

But, despite the issues I have with Ms Bouattia’s appointment in particular, they are not my primary motivation for writing this article. Put simply, our union is no longer fit for purpose. Her appointment is merely symbolic of how ‘lost’ – in the words of Labour MP and former NUS President Wes Streeting – the NUS has become. As Harry Samuels, NUS delegate for Oxford University, eloquently explained on Newsnight on Thursday, this appointment is simply the ‘straw that has broken the camel’s back’. At the latest count – one day after the election – at least 7 universities are debating disassociating themselves from the NUS (including Oxford and Cambridge). I argue that it is indeed time students had an alternative union. We need a union that is truly democratic, open and appeals to all, not just a narrow few. Everyone knows those involved with the NUS are not representative of the whole student population – just look at voter turnout numbers for delegate elections. The NUS has become tainted to the extent that so many of us just don’t want to get involved.

Never mind the rights and wrongs of Ms Bouattia refusing to back a motion condemning ISIS (that was admittedly more complex than is being portrayed by some of her critics), what is the NUS doing trying to pass a motion that condemns ISIS (and US foreign policy) anyway? Do they think ISIS gives two hoots? Are they representing the views of a majority of students when they criticise US policy in such blanket terms? Maybe, who knows. The point is the representatives have not been elected to express their opinions on global politics on behalf of the rest of us. Just have a look down the list of motions passed at the latest conference (when you actually manage to find the list of the motions in their entirety that is – not an easy task, such is the transparency and openness of our union). How many of those motions are directly relevant to students in this country? Not as high a proportion as you might expect. We should have a union that spends all its time talking about real student issues, not one that spends so much time debating grand geo-political issues that are the business of other forums.  Speaking to an NUS delegate who was present at the conference, her exasperation over the amount of time spent discussing irrelevant political issues, which left less time to discuss vital issues such as doctors’ notes and concessions, UCAS name-blind applications, student parents and carers to name a few, was clear.

Furthermore, whilst I am not naïve enough to think that national political loyalties can be completely separated from student politics, I was truly astounded by the extent of political partisanship on display at the conference. Watching via video link, seeing delegate after delegate eagerly rush up on stage to bash the government in no uncertain terms, I couldn’t help but wonder who these delegates thought had voted for our current government in the first place. Now I must stress I am not seeking to defend our government by making this point. The point is that we should have a union that honestly recognises the variety of views the people it claims to represent hold. We should have a union that doesn’t hide away from the fact that on some issues a proportion of us will think one way whilst others think another. I would never condemn an individual for expressing their personal views – provided they are not inciting hatred that is – but there is a time and a place to be measured in those views. To the delegate that declared his commitment to socialism and then marched off the stage with his fist held aloft, I ask whether he thinks the majority of people he represents hold the same view? There is nothing wrong with expressing one’s own views – in fact it is vital – but there is also nothing wrong with accepting that not everyone you represent shares them. So be honest, say that you and a significant proportion of the people you represent think this way, whilst a significant proportion think another. In this internet age is it really so difficult to run a poll that would enable you to gauge the views of all those you represent, rather than just those who voted for you? I know we are not used to democracy working in such a way in this country. It often seems that the winners simply make the rules, representing those that voted for them rather the whole population. Well, here I am arguing that this is wrong. Our democracy is flawed. Surely if anyone can work towards improving it, it is the students of today who will go on to be the political, economic and social leaders of the future? We need a union for all students that seeks to work with whoever is in power to achieve the best possible outcomes for all of its members. Who is likely to negotiate a better deal for all students – the representative who begins from the premise that our government is evil, or the representative who presents a reasoned and impartial case, explaining that 70% of students polled (for example) would be more likely to vote for a party that takes action on a certain issue? We should be coming together, collaborating to achieve relevant aims the vast majority of us can agree on. The NUS needs to change, or it needs to be replaced.

Where exactly we go from here I’m not sure. I intend to hold discussions with a variety of power-brokers within Durham, such as Durham Student Union officers and college presidents; to propose motions at JCR meetings condemning the NUS for their appointment of Ms Bouattia and calling for drastic reform; and to coordinate with people who hold similar beliefs from across the country. If you would be interested in raising awareness about the issues engulfing the NUS and in helping pressure our union into reforming, please don’t hesitate to get in touch. I have no doubt there are an abundance of people within the NUS who have done and are doing a lot of good work for all students. But their voices are being drowned out by those who prioritise their own narrow political agendas over the needs of the students they are supposed to represent. Far more unites us than divides us; we need a union that shows that.

Image: NUS