Race to the White House: The Republican Primaries

By Joe Slater

Donald Trump and Ben Carson currently lead in the polls
Donald Trump and Ben Carson currently lead in the polls

It is sometimes hard to believe that there is still around four months until the first state primary for the Republican presidential nomination begins, nine months before the Republican Convention in Ohio formally announces the party’s candidate and another thirteen months to go before all Americans head to the polls and elect their leader. This is the nature of American politics; it’s long, loud and staggeringly expensive. It is a remarkable electoral system that seems to dominate American culture for years at a time while making heroes and villains of its contestants in equal measure. The current Republican battle, however, appears to have taken things to another level.

The giant elephant in the contest of course is Donald Trump. From afar it can look to many like one big joke, a rich man’s vanity project that could only gain actual political support in a place like the US. This assumption is dangerously incorrect; while Trump’s persona is unquestionably ridiculous, his ability to combine economic populism with fervent right-wing nationalism has made visible the fear and resentment within much of the national electorate. There are others though, within this sizeable Republican field, attempting to stoke anger with similar tactics, whether it’s Texas Senator Ted Cruz or former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee. To fully explain the prominence of non-politicians like Trump, neurosurgeon Dr Ben Carson or former Hewlett Packard CEO Carly Fiorina in this contest, it is important to look a little deeper than specific policy offerings.

The strong support for three non-politicians is surely yet another result of the ‘anti-politics’ wave that is seemingly afflicting all Western democracies. Yet the Republican Party has already witnessed the rise of the Tea Party, a movement that is itself anti-establishment and is to blame for the current struggle to find a new Speaker of the House of Representatives. It may be that Trump is simply the newest way for those frustrated conservatives to express their displeasure. In Ben Carson the Republicans have a man with all the anti-Washington zeal of Trump but without the divisive rhetoric (his recent comments blaming the victims of the Oregon shooting for not fighting back aside).

While there is clearly early momentum behind Trump it is important to reemphasise just how long the process is, as well as how quickly things can change. In October 2007 Hilary Clinton was up by 25% in her race against Barack Obama while Rudy Giuliani was leading the Republican contest (with eventual winner John McCain in third). Most pollsters do not anticipate any of the three current frontrunners to win the eventual nomination; they use measures like fundraising and endorsements from fellow politicians to judge who the real favourite is. Yet even here conventional wisdom has failed; Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker was widely considered a leading candidate, someone who could appeal both to the conservative base and the Republican establishment, yet his collapse in the polls led him to quit the race after only two debates.

There are two other candidates widely tipped by the political media and supported by the political establishment. Former Governor Jeb Bush and current Senator Marco Rubio, both from Florida, are battling to become the favoured choice of the moderate wing of the party. It is another quirk of the American system that a Bush and a Clinton are once again leading candidates to become president; there is, however, evidence that both are suffering from growing antipathy toward their respective political dynasty. Rubio, on the other hand, has visibly grown into the race; he has a personable charisma and a political career eerily reminiscent of the then Senator Obama.

This contest has already made fools of political pundits who dare to try and predict it. As unlikely as ‘President Trump’ seems, remember what was said about Jeremy Corbyn or even Bernie Sanders in the Democratic race. There’s a long way to go before the voters of Iowa and New Hampshire formally begin proceedings. And as the long Summer of Trump fades it’s impossible to say what will happen next.

Photograph: DonkeyHotey via Flickr