Has DICCU publicity gone too far?

By Adam Carnall
As you might have found it hard to avoid finding out, this week is the Durham Intercollegiate Christian Union’s week of evangelistic events. I expect that the majority of students at Durham at one point or another complain to their friends about the barrage of leaflets, posters, Facebook posts, emails and other associated publicity that surround this week.
However DICCU is only one of many societies at Durham with an agenda and an active campaigning role within the University. It’s extremely important that these groups should be allowed to campaign to change the world in whatever way they believe will make it better, but still DICCU’s publicity seems to draw the greatest general condemnation of any society on campus. So what exactly is it about this week that’s different, and why do so many people seem to be left with an unpleasant taste in their mouth after being confronted by DICCU’s publicity material?
First things first, it’s important to recognise that this isn’t just a problem at Durham. In 2012, the Oxford Intercollegiate Christian Union provoked a backlash over particularly aggressive advertising tactics used in their mission week. More recently at Aberystwyth, student Rachel Evans said, in response to their Christian Union’s recent leafleting campaign:
“I’m so tired of having these things shoved in your face every other day; if people want to join CU they can see them on the union website and at the fresher’s fair [sic] like all the other societies. Their need to indoctrinate shouldn’t overrule mine to buy a bloody sandwich and go to the library in peace.”
Whilst it is of course the right of any society to advertise in any way it sees fit, within the confines of the law and University and Students’ Union policy, I’d like to highlight three aspects of DICCU’s campaigning which strike me as unpleasant and, I believe, provoke the negative reaction apparent from many within the student body.
This is… aggressive
When was the last time you were approached in the street and asked whether you’d be interested in trying out for the University’s football team? How about whether you’d be interested in learning about Japanese culture? Nobody likes being approached on Silver Street Bridge by a man trying to sell them a joke book, so why does DICCU think people are going to respond well to being accosted in the street and told all about a series of events they can come to and learn more about Jesus.
One student who wished to remain anonymous described her experience from last week:
“I was approached by a member of DICCU at the bottom of the steps to the DSU. The girl in question was very friendly, smiling broadly and obviously keen to get her message out there. Unfortunately a little too keen. As it was close to the hour, many students were making their way out of, to and between lectures. I was in a huge rush as I had to get from the science site to Elvet Riverside very quickly otherwise I would be late for an important seminar. Everyone knows that the pavements there can get crowded in the rush, and she was standing in the middle of it, darting around shoving leaflets in people’s faces.
People didn’t have the time and weren’t interested – they wanted to get to where they were going. I was stopped as I tried to get past whilst she darted in front of me to grab the attentions of two other students. As I attempted to squeeze past, with a polite “excuse me” she wheeled around and said, “Here, have a leaflet”, pushing it into my hand. I didn’t take it, I was in a rush and didn’t appreciate having a leaflet forced upon me. I imagine many of the other people felt the same way, and from the litter of leaflets on the pavement a few steps down not a lot of them appreciated the gesture.”
Surely it’s enough to publicise your society by putting up posters, webpages and by leaving flyers around campus for people to read if they are interested, rather than forcing others to hear your message in this way.
This is… underhanded
Of course the answer to the question I posed in the previous section about why DICCU thinks approaching people to ask them to come and learn about Jesus is a good idea is simple: they don’t. In fact DICCU often seems to try to disguise the fact that the events they run have anything to do with Christianity at all. It’s like some kind of timeshare apartment sales pitch.
Based upon my experience from previous years, walking past the Students’ Union building this week you’re much more likely to be asked whether you’d like a free lunch than whether you’d be interested in learning about Jesus. It’s this kind of attempt to obscure the point of the event people are being asked to attend that leaves those who do know what the underlying message is going to be feeling like there’s something quite decidedly wrong with advertising in this way. Given that I’ve been assured by many a DICCU member that their message is the most important news I’ll ever hear, it seems odd that they feel the need to dress it up with a free lunch to make people feel as if it’s worth going along to.
A related issue for me is the type of title DICCU chooses to use for the talks they run. A talk last Friday was entitled “Has science replaced God?” This strikes me as a strange title for an event at which someone is going to stand up and make the case against the question posed in the title, but nobody is going to get up and argue for it. Having a one sided event at which a speaker attempts to prove a point is completely fair enough but it betrays a lack of integrity to dress it up as an unbiased debate.
This is… targeting vulnerable students
Those of you who have perused the publicity material which is being spread around this week might have noticed a whole class of events specifically aimed at international students. This is just one example of a series of events DICCU uses to target the most vulnerable students at Durham and attempt to convince them of their beliefs.
Whether it’s running a weekend away for prospective first years the summer before they arrive, texting a toastie or a sustained attempt to offer conversion through companionship to international students, DICCU have developed an insidious methodology for propagating their beliefs based on approaching the shyest, loneliest and most uncertain students at Durham University.
Now it might sound extremely petty and small minded of me to argue that it’s wrong to offer kindness and companionship to vulnerable students; who cares if they have to listen to a bit about Jesus if they’re spending time with a caring group of friends? The fact of the matter is however that the University and Students’ Union work hard to provide safe and friendly environments for vulnerable students through nightline, through college welfare and through the University counselling service.
Whilst these systems aren’t perfect they are for the most part very good, and I think it has to be agreed that they’re a lot better than any form of help that’s conditional on accepting a set of beliefs, particularly one which is decided upon by an independent society with no form of unbiased oversight. This is particularly true given the unpleasant nature of some of the beliefs that DICCU have been associated with in the past.
In short, whilst it is, and should remain the right of DICCU to decide upon the best way to spread their message, it has to be questioned as to whether or not their current tactics are contributing positively towards the student experience at Durham University, and as to whether or not these practices are ethically and morally responsible.
Perhaps you disagree with this article. Palatinate firmly believes in your freedom of speech, so email comment@palatinate.org.uk with your take.
Photograph: Therealslimstacy
