Rihanna’s mosque snaps are a cultural triumph

The Sheikh Zayed Grand in Abu Dhabi. Photograph: Suwaif
The Sheikh Zayed Grand in Abu Dhabi.

By Ellie de la Bedoyere

 

Once again we’ve tried so hard not to step on people’s toes that we’ve tripped off the edge of common sense into a bland world of political correctness which continuously becomes that little bit harder to climb our way back out of. On this occasion we’ve tumbled over in our haste to apologise for Rihanna’s photo shoot in the most famous mosque in the Arab Emirates, the ‘Sheikh Zayed Grand.’

But then again, why wouldn’t we hurry to apologise? According to America’s Daily News, Rihanna is responsible for “bringing a little more instability to the Middle East.” On the surface this story doesn’t reflect well on her: these “racy photos” (Daily Mail) were taken at a place of worship, without prior permission and as a result she was asked to leave as her pictures did not fit in with the sanctity of the mosque. After skimming these provocative articles it seems only rational to dismiss Rihanna as a disrespectful, disgraceful and immoral human being.

However, before making your final judgements take a look at the pictures themselves. What you will find are several outrageously beautiful photographs of an elegant, young woman respectfully dressed in a full black jumpsuit and headscarf only just outshone by the striking, impossibly white and utterly majestic backdrop.

It is hard to fit the Daily Mail’s description of “racy” with her poses, which are instead modest, tasteful and of a high-fashion calibre – not even vaguely provocative or sexy. In fact, she is dressed so appropriately that the Daily Mail can only resort to criticising her “red lipstick and crimson nail polish” – how very daring, you’d have thought we still lived in the age of Downton. And really, there’s not a lot you can do to avoid any hint of sexiness when such a gorgeous woman is placed amidst such arresting surroundings.

The most contentious picture is the one of her lying on her back which she instagrammed with the caption ‘#notanlines’. Is this an offensive affront on Muslim belief or an antagonistic comment about Muslim women and their failure to seize their rights? Rather, is this not an amusing, subtle comment on cultural diversity?

If you’ve managed to disentangle yourself from the PC frenzy then perhaps you can recognise a little humour, regardless of your religion. Rihanna can only be blamed for daring to be so bold as to even mention cultural differences in this ‘diplomatic’ age.

let’s not pretend she’s campaigning for more culture in popular media or attempting to educate the world on cultural diversity

Nevertheless, there is no denying that what Rihanna did was bold. And by this I mean, she probably should have asked permission. Also, let’s not pretend she’s campaigning for more culture in popular media or attempting to educate the world on cultural diversity: all of these things are merely happy by-products.  Of course she’s exploiting this beautiful religious centre to create a beautiful picture. But then again, so what?  Is it disturbing worship? Is it corrupting a place of holiness? Does it add to Islam’s unfortunate press? Is it really that inappropriate?

Or is it actually very appropriate – a striking, strong woman dressed in hijab, embracing her beauty and independence in a Muslim way and giving the magnificence of Muslim culture its rightful recognition in the public sphere. The only ugliness in this picture is the Western reflex reaction of disgust.

Photograph: Suwaif