UKIP is not the answer to Britain’s problems

by David Hynes
Give them an inch and they’ll take a mile. Such has been the reaction of UKIP supporters to their recent showing in the Eastleigh by-election, a second-place finish the irrefutable proof that a new age of British politics has arrived. A ‘breath of fresh air’ was how Nick Bradley described the party in his Palatinate article. Like a lot of the writing on the subject, Bradley’s piece is an apt reflection on UKIP itself: all rhetoric and no substance.
So many are the spurious claims contained within Bradley’s article that it is hard to know where to begin. Describing UKIP’s recent by-election results as ‘phenomenal’ (just to clarify, none of which they actually won), Bradley predicts that come the next general UKIP will field a ‘large number of candidates…and will receive a large proportion of the vote’.
On what grounds this judgement is based is hard to tell. The most recent Yougov tracker pole put UKIP’s support at 4% and 3% among 18-24s and 25-39s respectively. This supports a study published in the European Journal of Political Research, which concluded that the core UKIP vote ‘is concentrated among men, older generations, the financially insecure and citizens who read anti-immigrant and Eurosceptic newspapers’. Electoral victories are not based on such skewed demographic foundations.
So much for Bradley’s ‘party of the people’ then. Even if we suspend reality and pretend that UKIP are a ‘people’s party’, some of Bradley’s conclusions are still baffling. Take for example city bonuses, which the evil EU is busy trying to cap. It would appear to me that ‘public opinion’ would be in favour of a cap on often extravagant payments to financiers – few topics provoke hostility in today’s society quite like the profligacy of the banking sector. Similarly, one of UKIP’s policies is to encourage the private sector to launch ‘partnerships’ with the NHS. Is further privatisation of the health service really what the ‘people’ want?
By far the most bewildering aspect is the faith Bradley puts in UKIP’s economic credentials. The fact that UKIP leader Nigel Farage was a city-trader apparently makes him the perfect candidate to run the country (incidentally, a rationale which would deem my sister, a primary school teacher, fit to run the education department), as if the City was not implicated enough in the economic malaise Britain is staggering through.
Regardless, UKIP’s policies are ‘what the economy needs to succeed’. This begs the obvious question: to which policies exactly is Bradley referring? On the ‘policy page’ (a generous description) of UKIP’s website, their ideas for the economy consist of a few bullet-points which would struggle to fill the back of a napkin.
However, here Bradley can only partly be blamed. He is clearly from the largely dysfunctional but strangely resilient ‘if it’s broken, deregulate it’ school of thought. After all, who needs policy when you’ve got ideology? However, for the rest of us – who perhaps are not so enamoured with a system of unrestrained, free-market capitalism which is pushing this country towards an unprecedented triple-dip recession, has heralded an era of stagnant wages and living standards, and delivered mass unemployment – some different ideas might be more reassuring.
Of course, no article on UKIP could possibly be complete without the denouncement of the party’s raison d’être, the European Union. Thankfully Bradley reveals the true nature of the body, ‘which increasingly resembles a totalitarian nation-state’. Unfortunately, Bradley is clearly not aware of the meaning of ‘totalitarian’ (nor ‘nation-state’ for that matter), which the Oxford English Dictionary defines as ‘a system of government which tolerates only one political party…and which usually demands the complete subservience of the individual to the State’. Even die-hard Eurosceptics would acknowledge that such a description is factually incorrect.
Indeed, it is somewhat ironic that Bradley cites UKIP’s results in European Parliamentary elections as evidence of their public support, only then to label the EU as totalitarian. All of this should surprise no one. It is the favoured method of the right-wing press to dumb-down political discourse to the point that they can then use such meaningless and misleading phrases to shape political dialogue. If Bradley’s is the kind of sophisticated political analysis that awaits us at a potential EU referendum, then the Eurocrats have little to fear.
Going from Bradley’s article, it would appear that UKIP is now the opposition party par excellence, as Labour are merely ‘foolish clowns’. This view disagrees slightly with recent comprehensive polling undertaken by Lord Ashcroft (that loony left-winger) which found that if there were an election tomorrow, those ‘foolish clowns’ would pick up 109 marginal seats and form a government with a majority of 84.
The truth is that UKIP is a glorified protest party. Unashamedly populist, they promise everything to everyone. After all, with no power (or prospect of) comes no responsibility. The glaring paradox of UKIP is that if they do become more popular, the very message that will have delivered them that popularity will have to be diluted as they realise that political slogans do not translate into coherent policy.
In all of this there is a message that the mainstream parties desperately need to grasp. For too long, the concerns of white working class communities have been ignored, their legitimate worries over housing, jobs and immigration passed over in the mad rush to secure the votes of Middle England. It is this sense of abandonment that has led to the rise of UKIP, and until recently the BNP, who made a conscious effort to listen. All of the parties must make more of an effort to reach out to the alienated. British politics is in need of change but UKIP can never deliver it. A breath of fresh air? A load of hot air more like.
