“Boo!”: Horror should be about more than jump-scares!

By Justin Browning

With Halloween upon us again, it’s time for the obligatory article on horror films. While most of us enjoy a good scary movie that can get us leaping behind the sofa in terror, it’s fair to say that the horror genre is quite hit-and-miss. It seems that every spooky gem comes at the cost of several dull rehashes of tired clichés.

More than any other genre, horror suffers from unoriginality – most notorious of all is the reliance on jump-scares. I myself am a total wimp when it comes to these, but just because a film succeeded in scaring me by going “boo!” it doesn’t mean that it is good horror. It’s very easy to build tension up to a terrifying payoff with the modern horror formula, but I end up feeling cheated when a film sticks to playing it safe like this. It doesn’t feel like the film has earned my terror, and the whole thing feels cheap as a result. I could list off some examples, but they’re so forgettable that you probably wouldn’t recognise them anyway.

There are some directors, however, that manage to work in the usual template but turn it into something fresh, the most notable of which is James Wan. Insidious and The Conjuring work well within the standard horror formula – they have familiar plots and largely stick to jump-scare tactics –but they avoid being generic in a number of other ways.

For one thing, the scares are just so damn good! After watching that hand-clapping scene in The Conjuring, I couldn’t go near a wardrobe for months. They both also had moments that fell flat, especially the final scenes of Insidious which broke the golden rule by fully revealing the demonic villain, at which point he became hilariously cartoonish. Up to that point, however, I had felt nothing but sheer terror while watching; accompanied by the most beautifully horrific soundtrack I have ever heard.

Most importantly, the key to the success of these movies is that they balanced the efforts to frighten the audience with time spent building genuine atmosphere (especially in the case of the tense first half of The Conjuring) so that a sense of unease runs throughout. It seems that many other directors forget that horror is as much about making the audience’s skin crawl as it is about making them jump out of their skin altogether.

Unfortunately, Wan’s unoriginality often catches up with him, proving that sticking to familiar ideas usually leads to failure. Both sequels to the films mentioned above are good examples. Insidious 2 is simply a repeat of the first movie in tone and style, and the result is predictably uninteresting. The worst culprit, however, is The Conjuring 2. The film is the epitome of predictability; it’s infuriating to have to sit through a minute or two of build-up to a lazy “boo, gotcha!” and still be frightened because of the calculating use of loud noises and spooky-looking demon nuns. It was received with a level of positivity so baffling that I’m not sure if I saw the same movie as everyone else.

Fortunately, the horror scene is currently being coloured by a few flicks which seek to play it less safe. A great example of this is The Babadook, the fantastic directorial debut from Jennifer Kent which succeeds not only in rejecting almost every aspect of conventional horror, but also in portraying Australia as the most depressing place on earth. In fact, labelling this as “horror” is quite misleading, and explains a lot of the hate that it received from the kind of people who crave a healthy dose of proper scares. The Babadook works more as a psychological drama-horror hybrid in which the eponymous monster represents the loss suffered by the mother and child at the story’s centre (yes, it’s arthouse too).

The Babadook’s design is distinctly campy, which only serves to make it more uniquely disturbing. The mere idea of it becomes haunting, helped by the fact that we never clearly see the monster; the focus is skewed more towards the effects that its presence has on the family. By almost never trying to make the audience jump, the film turns to different techniques, focusing on the growing bleakness and feeling of helplessness that overwhelm the story. The result is a cohesive film steeped in a dreadful atmosphere that inspires a deeper form of fear than the sharp yet brief scares of more conventional fare.

Even further away from the standard definition of horror we find The Witch, a film which has no interest in “scaring” the audience in the usual sense at all. Its priority is instead to deeply unsettle us. Time and again the music rises to an unbearable crescendo of squealing strings, usually accompanying a long shot of uncomfortable images. The Witch seeks to create the same disturbed feelings in us that we perceive in its characters as they struggle to make a living in the frontier of colonial America while sinisterly occult forces press in on the family. It’s a nightmarish masterpiece made all the more unpleasant by the fact that the whole film was based on real folk tales.

Unfortunately, ambition does not always translate into success. It Follows impressed critics and left audiences fairly pleased when it released a couple of years ago, and frankly I have no idea why. This was a slightly-above-average film with an interesting premise based on the idea of a monster-turned-STD that eternally pursues its victims until they transmit the curse through sex. Sadly, the whole thing was a bit of a mess, and the creepy concept clashed with painfully try-hard indie direction and a retro-videogame-inspired soundtrack that would have been better suited to a Zelda movie. Just because it’s never been done before, that doesn’t mean you should do it!

All I’m trying to say is that bad horror movies are all too common, but you shouldn’t write them all off as a result. There are some that stick to a familiar format and still manage to entertain and scare in a satisfying way. And while the more original works of recent times aren’t for everyone, they certainly manage to bring new brands of terror to the genre. This Halloween season, resist the urge to break out the classics or the mainstream rubbish and try something new – you just might be surprised by what you see.

‘Insidious’ and ‘The Babadook’ on can be streamed on Netflix and you can watch ‘The Conjuring’ and ‘It Follows’ on Amazon Prime.

Image: Faye Chua