Durham law professors join calls for rape porn reform
Two members of Durham Law School have commented on a new report into pornography featuring images of non-consensual sexual activity.
An open letter to the Prime Minister has also been written in light of new calls to close the “loophole” in extreme pornography legislation.
Professors Erika Rackley and Clare McGlynn’s comments follow the report by the End Violence Against Women Coalition, titled ‘Deeds or Words?’ which found that the law in this area is in “urgent” need of reform.
Rape Crisis London and 100 other signatories have written to the Prime Minister demanding he take steps to close the gap in the law.
In 2008 legislation on extreme pornography was brought in to criminalise the possession of any pornography which depicts life-threatening injury, serious injury, bestiality or necrophilia.
However, images of rape were absent from the legislation.
Rape Crisis South London campaigner Fiona Elvines, who has conducted research into what is currently available online legally in England and Wales, described this as a “serious omission.”
She added, “This is not about making a distinction between real and simulated rape and child sexual abuse, with the latter being perfectly lawful to possess if it is considered ‘fantasy’ and actors are over 18.
“Permitting the possession of depictions of sexual violence as entertainment glorifies, trivialises and normalises such abuse – at a time when government statistics estimate that 85,000 women and girls are raped each year.”
Professor McGlynn, of Durham University said: “While those who view extreme pornography will not necessarily go on to commit sexual offences, their use of such material sustains a culture in which rape and sexual violence is normalised; in which a woman’s ‘no’ is not taken seriously; in which equality and dignity are not protected.
“The criminalisation of the possession of pornographic images of rape can be justified because of the ‘cultural harm’ of this form of extreme pornography.
“This is not a simplistic argument about rape pornography causing rape. It is undeniable that the proliferation and tolerance of such images and the messages they convey contributes to a cultural climate where sexual violence is condoned.”
The open letter to David Cameron refers to the recent convictions of Mark Bridger and Stuart Hazell, who had both used violent and misogynistic pornography as part of their murders of young girls, and draws attention to the fact that the possession of rape pornography is already criminalised in Scotland where law-makers took its harm into account when legislating.
The Director of the writers of the report, the leader of End Violence Against Women Coalition, Holly Dustin, called on the Prime Minister to act:
“’Rape porn’ glorifies sexual violence and undermines the government’s work.
“It sends a contradictory message about the seriousness with which sexual violence is taken. We…urge the Prime Minister to act urgently to close this loophole.”
Professor Rackley commented: “The extreme pornography legislation is in urgent need of reform. The current law excludes of the vast majority of pornographic images of rape.
“Pornographic images of rape are easily and freely accessible online.”
The Professors have drafted changes to the law together, and concluded:
“We await the Prime Minister’s response.”
Photograph: Nicoletta Asciuto

