New system for college allocation implemented

Snow

by Sally Wardle and Harriet Line

The University has changed the way students are allocated to colleges.

The previous allocations process meant that once accepted by a department, Senior Tutors could choose whether or not a student would be admitted to their college. Those who did not meet their criteria would be assigned to an alternative college.

This criteria varied by college, but decisions were largely based upon UCAS information and subject quotas.

However, under plans that have been trialled during the current admissions cycle, students are now automatically assigned to their first choice college.

In the trial simulations, first choice applicants will not be selected randomly if their college has a place for them – they will be selected automatically.

A major aim of the simulations that are being trialled during the current admissions cycle is to identify the optimum period for selection so that all applicants are treated fairly and in exactly the same way.

The trial will be reviewed as to whether it meets its aims and a final decision made in September – in time for any changes to the college allocation system to be made clear to prospective students applying for entry in 2014.

“Passed” applicants (those whose chosen colleges are oversubscribed) will be allocated a college automatically, but these will be in the minority.

The automated process will also apply to applicants who have stated no college preference in their UCAS application.

Describing the motives for this trial, Vice-Chancellor Professor Christopher Higgins stated: “We have realised the previous allocations system was certainly not transparent and actually wasn’t fair.

“Colleges might have been making selections of students without defining what the criteria are.

“Before, students were putting the college first, there were spaces, but the college didn’t take them – that is not right.”

University College is highly oversubscribed, yet the Vice-Chancellor commented that 20% of current students did not put it as their first choice, a fact which demonstrates how previously, college allocations was “a very, very byzantine process.”

However there has been a mixed reaction to this change in policy.

Some students argue that by removing selection of students from the college’s control, the allocations process undermines the collegiate system.

Tom Bishop, President of St Chad’s, stated his concern over the new policy.

“I appreciate that any policy has to be fair and transparent, but my chief concern is that students are not being treated as people.

“Our personal statements will make no difference to whether we get into our preferred college. We were accepted into the University on merit. Now our chances of getting into a college will be based on chance. I don’t see why colleges need to be taken out of the picture entirely.”

I don’t see why colleges need to be taken out of the picture entirely

A report into the ‘Automated College Allocations Process’ recounts that whilst “a majority of Board members accepted the need for the new system […] concerns were expressed as to how this would affect the ‘unique flavour’ of each college community particularly in highly selecting Colleges.”

Christopher Higgins commented however that “it would be unfair to put a student into one particular college, over and above students who really want to go to that college just because they happen to be skilled on the trombone or whatever else.”

There are similar concerns that using a randomised allocation process at oversubscribed colleges will create an unbalanced community and one perhaps with students ill-suited for the environment.

For example, only a select few colleges offer Choral or Organ Scholarships and music tuition to their students, but under the new policy an interest in such an endeavour would not give a student preference to that college if it is oversubscribed.

According to the policy, students will only be given greater preference for a college if they have particular disability, religious or dietary requirement or if they receive a Vice-Chancellor’s Scholarship for sports, music or the arts or for academic excellence.

DSU President Archie Dallas recognises, “[college allocation] is an incredibly complicated system and I sympathise with the University.”

He argues that rather than undermine college identity and reputation, the new system will “force these colleges to project their identity more clearly.”

The Vice-Chancellor agreed with these claims, suggesting that colleges will have to clearly advertise what sort of environment they offer, in order to attract appropriate students.

He maintained that “Student choice should be paramount rather than college choice.”

However, the Vice-Chancellor later commented, “We shouldn’t forget that the vast majority of students actually don’t choose a college, or if they do it’s almost random anyway.”

Whilst the policy change itself has provoked mixed reactions, there are also concerns about the lack of student consultation on its implementation.

Christopher Higgins suggests there has been “widespread consultation” about the policy change:

“The student body should have been aware because it should have been told through your JCRS, because the JCR Presidents were all very aware.”

The ‘Automated College Allocations Process’ report marks July 4th 2012 as one of the key discussions with Heads of Colleges about making a change in policy. As a result of that meeting, plans for the automation process were expedited.

However, according to several JCR Presidents who spoke to Palatinate, the matter was not directly brought to their attention until October 28th 2012. The report, released this month, was the first time they had seen anything on paper at all.  Apparently the policy was discussed at one informal lunch with the Vice-Chancellor, but there was no notice that the issue would come up.

Although largely in favour of the new system, Archie Dallas commented “If you are making a big change, it has to come to the right places. If it is the sort of thing that happens over a social occasion, that’s not acceptable.”

Whilst the new policy strives to create transparency in the admissions process, one University College student commented on the lack of information available to applicants:

“Students are definitely not aware of how the allocation process works and only have rumours to base their decisions on.

“If I was applying now, in light of this new policy, I would think twice about applying for an oversubscribed college.

“It would be better to guarantee your place in another, similar college, than be assigned one in a randomised process that didn’t suit your tastes.”

James Proudfoot, a third year at Collingwood, added “students who don’t receive their first choice could be placed in a college with wildly different values than the one they originally wanted to go to.”

Such criticism has led to calls for students to be able to select a second choice college on their application forms.

Professor Christopher Higgins agrees that modifications may need to be made after this trial year, but argues that this year the system “was put in quite urgently,” and so such changes were not feasible.

The ‘Automated College Allocations Process’ report describes the review stage of the process, which will take the form of meetings in May, July and September 2013.

We shouldn’t resist change just for the hell of it

This “analysis stage” will “look at how communities emerge from the process with an emphasis on looking at gender balance and the profile of student interests.”

Archie Dallas urged students to consider the policy:

“There might be a few teething problems, but in the long run it will be much better.

“I don’t want to just reject a system that could be better in the long run just as a knee-jerk reaction to change.

“I am willing to listen. It has got drawbacks and pros, but we shouldn’t resist change just for the hell of it.”

A spokesperson for the University has said that the term ‘randomised’, which has been applied to the process, is ‘misleading’. They state that automatic allocations are made within the context of getting within each college a good mix of students studying a broad range of subjects . In addition, they maintain that the automated element of the process is not being used to make decisions on behalf of the preference college of applicants who state a choice on their UCAS application. These applications are still being considered by the Senior Tutor at their preference college.

[poll id=”9″]

Photograph: Samuel Spencer