A response: why ignorance of trans* issues is wrong

by Bethan Nye

Has there ever been a more tiresome exercise than arguing against people about a problem they refuse to admit exists? Possibly, but it still irritates me to my very core. I am referring to the article “Political correctness gone mad once again?” by Nick Bradley, published by this very student newspaper on the 19th January. I am not going to go into detail about how offensive the article was (you all have minds and can read) because being offended is a transient feeling. No, I’m here to talk about how he was wrong – because that’s forever.

First of all, I’d like to congratulate the author on missing the point about how social change works – first you make a law to change official behaviour, then you educate the populace about discrimination to gradually effect social change; see: gay rights.

Secondly, I’d like to congratulate him on the spectacular amount of research he must have done to conclude that transphobia doesn’t exist. I’ve read a vast amount of articles about people in the US, UK, South America and other countries who have been beaten, raped and murdered just for being trans* (lgbt.co.uk is a good resource for those who want further information) – but clearly I didn’t look deeply enough into all of these articles to find that they were fabrications. I compliment the author on his thoroughness.

I would also like to see his sources that conclude that being trans* is no longer a hindrance in “official life”. I do not know what he means by this, but I’m presuming that he won’t be citing  the 2002 study commissioned by Manchester Metropolitan University concluded that ‘the reality is that transsexual people are not given an equal footing with other employees’ (Whittle et al., 2002). Nor must he be talking about the statistics from the Association of Graduate Advisory Services which put the rate of trans* unemployment at more than three times that of the general population. They have found that of those trans* persons in work, 38% face harassment and trans* individuals are more likely to change jobs due to hostile working environments. This is despite legal prohibition of harassment, redundancy and dismissal of trans* persons under the Sex Discrimination Act 2000.  Certainly he cannot possibly to referring to the series of hoops that trans* people must jump through to receive basic medical treatment, and recognition of the gender by the Government.

Now, Suzanne Moore. The author fails to see what the problem is with her joke about Brazilian transsexuals – I will attempt to clarify. The problem is not (I believe) in itself the joke; it is the context surrounding it. The situation for trans* people in Brazil is not a good one: they are the smallest part of the LGBT+ minority in terms of numbers, and experience disproportionate rates of assault, including sexual, and murder. In this context the joke is less funny (murder, rape and violence tend to do that to jokes, those pesky buzzkills).

After this, the author talks about the concept that you can’t talk about a minority you are not a part of, and how this poses a vast threat to freedom of speech. Simply not true – Moore dragged this up instead of accepting that what she had written was offensive due to facts she was not aware of at the time. The vast majority of advocacy groups speak up for people who aren’t them – Barack Obama isn’t gay but still speaks up for gay marriage, fact fans. The author gets quite confused about freedom of speech – apparently in his world this means that everyone can say anything without fear of anyone speaking back or criticising what they just said – didn’t make sense to me either – and claims that journalists don’t have an obligation to defend minorities or must “walk on eggshells” around them (I assume this is a synonym for “do basic research” judging by the article content).

Finally, the author concludes this tract by describing how equalities legislation has meant that you can’t say or do anything offensive any more (horrible, right?) and how this is censorship of the media. Big news, Nick: the article got published, and it’s not censorship to expect journalists to do research and then point out if they haven’t done it.

The author complains of boredom, which begs the question of why he bothered to take time out of his day to write a whole article expressing how tedious he finds the struggle for equality. He ends with the saying of “sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me” and advises trans* people to “man up”. The offensive implications of the latter aside, I’m just curious that the author apparently has never heard of any suicides caused by verbal bullying. But then again, it’s not his job to do the research.

Oh, sorry – it is.

This article is in response to ‘Political correctness gone mad once again?‘ If you have any more thoughts, comment below, or tweet us @PalatiComment.

Photograph: Loz Flowers on Flickr