Examination concessions are not justifiable

by James Murray

Examination concessions are simply not justifiable within the current examination system. Having been assessed as dyslexic, I am entitled to 25% extra time on examinations, yet even to me this seems grossly unfair.

Assuming that examinations are meant as markers to society and prospective employers of our proficiency at performing certain tasks I cannot understand why those who will always be impaired at such tasks should therefore be entitled to effectively mask that impairment.

With few exceptions most people are generally constrained by the stringent timing of examinations. Given that such an onus is placed upon expediency it seems reasonable to assume that it is therefore considered a valuable skill by society and employers. If I am incapacitated in this way, why should I be allowed to compensate for it and present a false impression of my skills?

Dyslexia is just the extreme end of a spectrum of ability concerned with inputting and processing information. The test is based purely upon identifying a discrepancy between ability in certain mental faculties and others for example, conceptual understanding and phonetic reading expediency. The assessor simply has to judge whether they think that the discrepancy is sufficiently pronounced to justify deeming it ‘dyslexia’.

It seems reasonable to assume that examinations are supposedly used to differentiate people according to their abilities. A large part of this is being able to perform expediently (an ability which is presumably commensurable with dyslexia). If  then, this is one marker by which we deem it necessary to differentiate people regardless of their subject, how can it be justified to exempt the particularly slow from that aspect of examination competition. The answer is – it’s not.

However the reason we tolerate it is because we realise that to measure people’s expediency and conflate it with ability in any subject is foolhardy. Expediency is rarely necessary in professional life within the margins by which we are tested and is used in examinations merely as a convenient way to differential people in a society based upon competition which demands (a seemingly fair system of) differentiation in order to justify inequalities.

If we’re honest, examinations are not about identifying ability relative to a subject but relative to your peers. That is why we all get that little kick when we understand something the others have failed to grasp.

What the extra time concession represents is the contradiction which lies at the heart of meritocracy. We like to believe in competition and differentiation by merit so we can justify wealth and poverty, yet the system is compromised because we fail to recognise that in a society every individual is dependent upon the majority of others, and the great variety of their skills and proficiencies.