Russell Group hits back at fair access plans

Stuart Marshfield

The Russell group, consisting of 20 top education institutions, has reacted strongly to punishment threats by the head of the Office for Fair Access (OFFA) to force universities to meet admissions targets for poorer students.

Earlier this month, Professor Les Ebdon, the newly appointed head of the OFFA and vice-chancellor of the University of Bedfordshire, criticised the low admissions of students from disadvantaged backgrounds threatening to withdraw the right of universities to charge ÂŁ9000 tuition fees if targets were not met.

Ebdon further attacked university admissions by suggesting that one reason for low numbers of poorer students was simply because, at school, applicants had studied the wrong subjects.

Director General of the Russell Group, Dr Wendy Piatt, urged the central authority to consider the real problems within the education system and not to put the blame on university admissions.

The Russell Group is made up of 20 leading academic institutions across the country; including the Universities of Oxford, Cambridge, Bristol and Warwick. The group describe themselves as “committed to academic excellence in teaching and research”, in addition to establishing links to businesses and the public sector.

Piatt stated that the actual reason for low numbers of disadvantaged students was that they simply had not achieved the necessary level of A-level qualifications. The Russell Group have stated recently that exam results had confirmed that students from low income families were more unlikely to reach the top A-level grades.

Eric Thomas, president of Universities UK, agrees with Dr Piatt and suggests that the root cause of low admissions to top universities from disadvantaged areas is low achievement in 16-18 education.

Dr Piatt went on to say that criticism from the OFFA distracts from the real world problems, and insisted that efforts be put to use in helping Russell Group universities target the young students in deprived areas of the country that are the “hardest to reach”.

Professor Ebdon will take up his post as head of the OFFA later this year following his controversial appointment by Business Secretary Vince Cable.