Debate – do student politics really matter?
Whenever we vote in elections, attend a JCR meeting, or participate in the student community as a member of a sports team, musical group, political interest, community outreach project, welfare committee, or indeed by reading this newspaper, we all engage in the issues that matter to students. Students are known for their willingness to engage in political issues at University, and Durham is no exception.
Politics at JCR level has never been stronger. Van Mildert’s recent Presidential elections saw a record turnout of 71% with three candidates running, and mandated a well attended presidential debate as well as hustings. JCR Meetings are packed to the rafters, College Outreach Schemes reach throughout County Durham, and participation is not forced, but encouraged.
Student engagement is increasing everywhere. In St. Aidan’s, seven fresher candidates are contesting the position of Senior DSU Rep. Trevelyan have sustained unprecedented turnout in the DSU Sabbatical elections over the past three years.
I challenge anyone who criticises student involvement to walk through the front doors of any of these colleges into the garish 1960’s architecture and leave feeling the same way.
The packed halls of the DUS debating chamber are testament to consistently high levels of engagement in the world of politics. Students are constantly expressing political engagement, be it with a JCR, College, the University or the community of County Durham.
The apathy of students is not as widespread as critics suggest. Much of this criticism is directed towards the Student Union; yet we must remember that this is the same Union whose actions caused national notoriety over disaffiliation from the NUS, and who channelled student discontent into the postponement of 38 week lets last year, two examples of Durham students uniting to preserve their rights.
Significant student engagement can be seen in last year’s AV referendum and in the fees protests in London that dominated national news.
Sadly, such events are often manipulated to characterise student politics as violent and one-dimensional, yet protest is a form of political expression. Student politics dictates everything we do at university and beyond.
Having spent the past year as a Senior DSU Representative for my college, what struck me is that people care. Working with the Societies and Development Officer, it became clear to me that student engagement in politics should not be confined to the traditional forums of Parliament and the ballot box.
The Student Union currently boasts 212 Clubs and Societies. The prevalence of humanitarian groups such as the newly created and extremely popular UNICEF society, as well as youth political parties is testament to wider student engagement with politics and allows for the expression of personal interests in social issues.
I feel incredibly privileged to be a member of my JCR, and I know countless more who would say the same. We should not assess the strength of student politics based on statistical turnout of JCR Meetings, especially those which have been misinterpreted. Indeed, if the backlash from the recent Palatinate article on JCR participation is anything to go by, involvement in student politics is seen by many as a duty and a genuine privilege.
Whether you notice it or not, student engagement matters to all of us. University life is enriched by the people who are willing to get involved in student activity.
Students who participate in political activity are not a minority, but consist of every individual who engages in their JCR, university and beyond; their actions matter, and they should be celebrated.
NO by Chris McQuillan
There’s a degree of irony that, after having served a year as JCR Chair at Grey College and running unsuccessfully for the JCR Presidency, I find myself writing that student politics don’t really matter. I was very involved in college politics, trying to make a long-term difference and crafting a better JCR for future students.
Soon, though, new people filled every exec position. I passed into the infrequently read annals of JCR history swiftly and quietly.
Friends graduated and entered the world of work; I stayed to medieval history. Visiting friends in London and elsewhere has shown me that there is much, much more to life than the world of student politics.
Student politics can certainly be enthralling. The thrill of winning an election process and becoming part of the coveted Exec is certainly an admirable achievement, but it is an achievement on a personal level.
Nothing is achieved by simply being there. And even to those who do devote themselves to the position and organise thrilling bops, re-write constitutions and shore up JCR finances, they are sadly achievements that few appreciate or even notice.
To the majority of students in Durham, what is important is getting a degree, having good mates and some good nights out. The outrage that followed KluteGate exemplifies this. I can’t see the same scenes, reminiscent of Kim Jong-Il’s passing, ocurring if the DSU changes its logo.
I by no means wish to denigrate those in student politics. Many of them care deeply, and dedicate great amounts of time for the benefit of others. However, with the University attempting to impose greater control on JCR and DSU autonomy, there’s a limited impact anyone can really have in the grand scheme of things.
As students, we are under restrictions from the university when it comes to finances, events and protecting the long term interests of our fellow students (see the 38-week let campaign: successful at first, but simply delayed until the older students had left).
“Student memory” is a key problem with student politics. Every three or four years, the memory of what has come before passes into myth and legend.
As a result, the long-term impact of any individual’s impact on student politics can be very short lived. All it takes is a few mediocre successors to a great JCR President for everyone to forget how things really should be done.
I reiterate; the work done by those in student politics can be admirable. I’ve spoken to countless elected officers in colleges and at the DSU who care passionately about what they do and what they want to achieve. As JCR Chair, I myself took part in a redraft of the Grey College JCR Constitution so that we could register as a charity and retain a semblance of independence from the University.
At the time, it seemed that the future of everyone in Grey hinged on us making these decisions.
But in the end, even if we hadn’t registered as a charity, the lives of the majority of future students would probably not have changed significantly. The University will still, eventually, be able to make the changes it wants as it has significantly more financial backing and might than students ever will. As student politicians, we merely fought back the tide for a little while. Admirable? Yes. An effective use of time? Well, that’s more questionable.
The primary benefit of student politics is the change it makes to the individual. The confidence, the transferrable skills of team-work, time-management are opportunities that few other positions at university can offer. In that regard, student politics helps us to grow as people.
But, I would argue, similar skills can be attained through sports teams, theatre or employment. Should student politics be treated as the Holy Grail of Importance?
If student politics really mattered, we would be able to make real, long-term differences to the lives of students here.
Sadly, there is no guarantee we can. Our dedications would surely be better spent in a career, or a workplace, etching out a long-term future for ourselves and our future families.
Student politics may be admirable, but it must be kept in perspective: a short-term impact by people in short-term roles upon a student body who, within five years, will have forgotten their name.
If you keep this Palatinate then look back in two decades and ask yourself: were these issues ever really that important? Did they really matter in the end?
What do you think of our writers’ views? Comment below, or tweet us @PalatiComment

