Why people like Rod Liddle should talk at Durham

By Xander Phillips

As December approaches and the temperature drops, you can witness the steady emergence of snowflakes drifting aimlessly through the streets of Durham until their righteous fury is ready to be unleashed. An entire generation reduced to tears and stuttering at the prospect of hearing anyone who faintly disagrees with their utopian view of a politically correct society. An unfortunate demonstration of this occurred last year (at South College) when Rod Liddle was invited to speak, thereby causing an uproar and leaving a visibly shaken student body who had their ‘safe space’ invaded. This, of course, demonstrated the drastic overreaction our delightfully left-wing student body is so efficient at producing. 

The issue with the uproar and protest was not that the students disagreed with Mr Liddle but rather their desire to not hear him speak at all. This new mindset whereby those that are seen as disagreeable are no longer allowed to express their opinions in educational establishments is a mind-boggling one. Surely a university’s job is to open the minds of its students, providing them with both sides to a debate and then leaving them to make up their own minds. And if not the university’s job, then one could at least assume that the students themselves would seek to open their minds to other opinions and ideas they perhaps do not share. This is the natural course of debate and freedom of ideas that universities and the students within them should cherish. 

This, however, seems to be less true in the 21st century; social issues such as the trans-issue seem to no longer be a debatable topic, while colonial history can now only be viewed through a lens of apology and reparations. Both of these highly sensitive topics were brought up by Mr Liddle last December, prompting outcries and a university investigation. How has our cohort been so indoctrinated that we cannot even listen to opposing views on matters? And why did the small matter of a controversial opinion result in a university investigation? Clearly, this overreaction is aimed at discouraging the invitation of right-wing speakers in the future and amounts to a coordinated suppression of right-wing voices at universities, and therefore infringes on the ideals of both freedom of speech and freedom of expression. 

And, at the end of the day, the decision to invite Liddle, despite being controversial, is aimed at prompting and creating debate, and his invitation is founded on the ideals of both freedom of speech and expression. Values that should be cherished above all else, above the petty squabbling of politicians and nonsensical political correctness, above one’s own opinion and above the desire for a safe space. Freedom of speech is an idea everyone, bar tyrants and dictators, should want to get behind. It allows society to remain free and is one of the primary ideals differentiating the western world from nations such as China, Russia and North Korea. For, as one of the founding fathers of America once said, “If freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter” — George Washington. 

the decision to invite Liddle, despite being controversial, is aimed at prompting and creating debate

Therefore, the solution I would suggest to all those who would desire to see Mr Liddle banned from the Durham campus and censored would be to quote Oscar Wilde, “I may not agree with you, but I will defend to the death your right to make an ass of yourself.” And if you cannot even agree with that ideal or do not think Mr Liddle would make an ass of himself, then maybe it is time to listen and, perhaps, change your opinions on some matters. 

Image: CIH Housing via Flickr