The Camden conundrum: how the Holborn and St Pancras by-election could shape British politics for years to come

By Barny Weeden

On Tuesday 1st September, Sir Keir Starmer resigned as Member of Parliament for Holborn and St Pancras, just hours before Andy Burnham was due to make his maiden parliamentary speech as Prime Minister. The resulting by-election on 8th October, which comes amid speculation over an early general election, will provide an early indication of Burnham’s popularity. 

Stretching from wealthy Bloomsbury to working-class social housing estates, Holborn and St Pancras is a constituency of striking economic contrasts. It is also a Labour stronghold, held by the party since its establishment in 1983. Starmer became its MP in 2015, succeeding Frank Dobson, who represented the seat and its predecessor, Holborn and St Pancras South, for 36 years. 

Labour selected Sagal Abdi-Wali to defend the seat. The candidate fled war in Somalia as a child and has led Camden Council since May. However, the Green Party’s decision to field their national leader, Zack Polanski, has transformed the by-election from a straightforward succession contest into a national battleground for the British left. 

It was initially uncertain whether Polanski would stand. He lives in Hackney and previously insinuated that he might contest a North London seat, yet several other constituencies lie closer to home, namely Tottenham and Walthamstow. Although Polanski previously lived in Holborn and St Pancras, his decision to stand was notable. Describing his party as the “underdog” in the by-election, he won the Greens’ selection on 10th September, defeating Hamza Chowdhury, a councillor for Holborn and Covent Garden. Chowdhury positioned himself as a local alternative, criticising candidates who “disappear once the votes are counted” in a pointed reference to Polanski’s residence elsewhere. 

The Green Party’s decision to field their national leader, Zack Polanski, has transformed the by-election from a straightforward succession contest into a national battleground for the British left

Polanski’s decision to release campaign videos in Urdu, Bengali, and French sparked immediate debate. It typified the Green Party’s so-far successful strategy of capitalising on popular dissatisfaction with Labour’s position on Gaza – a priority issue for 41% of Pakistani and Bangladeshi Britons according to YouGov. However, critics questioned the video’s relevance to the local electorate. Oliver Cooper, former leader of the Conservative Party on Camden Council, cited 2021 Census data, noting that 139 residents in Holborn and St Pancras recorded Urdu as their main language. This number was fewer than those who reported Russian, Spanish, or French as their mother tongue, while the area’s South Asian population is predominantly Bangladeshi. 

This controversy raised broader questions about modern electioneering: does multilingual campaigning foster inclusivity, or risk treating communities as distinct electoral blocs? Shadow housing secretary Katie Lam described Polanski’s campaign video as “poisonous” and, comparing it to a leaflet written in Urdu circulated by Hannah Spencer in Gorton and Denton, demanded a total ban on non-English campaigning to protect “the language of public life”. Jonathon Reynolds, Secretary for Business and Trade, admitted to feeling “uncomfortable” about the strategy. The Greens defended the video, arguing that “democracy doesn’t discriminate by languages spoken”. 

The contest in Holborn and St Pancras has been further complicated by George Galloway’s decision to stand for the Workers Party of Britain. The former MP, elected seven times across five different constituencies, vowed to contest the seat “unless the Green Party comes to the table and makes us an offer we can’t refuse”. He confirmed his candidacy on 14th September, prompting the resignation of Chris Williamson, deputy leader of the Workers Party, who came out in support of Polanski, illustrating tensions amongst Labour’s left-wing challengers. 

This controversy raised broader questions about modern electioneering: does multilingual campaigning foster inclusivity, or risk treating communities as distinct electoral blocs?

Meanwhile, climate policy marks one of the clearest dividing lines between Labour and the Greens. Polanski has made the government’s position on North Sea oil and gas a focal point of his campaign, pointing to the proposed Jackdaw gas field. He accused Labour of “running scared” amid reports that the project’s approval would be delayed until after the by-election, a claim that Downing Street has denied. For Polanski, the by-election offers voters a direct choice between the Greens’ climate commitments and Labour’s attempts to balance net zero targets with continued fossil fuel extraction. 

Ultimately, the significance of this by-election extends far beyond who succeeds Starmer. Labour is defending a four-decade-long stronghold against a Green Party eager to prove that recent gains in Camden and beyond were not simply protest votes, but a springboard for parliamentary representation. Andrew Feinstein, an independent who finished second to Starmer in 2024, has stepped aside and endorsed Polanski, further reshaping the contest. With Galloway’s decision to stand adding a further challenge from the left of Labour, the campaign is already revealing the shifting dynamics of progressive politics in modern London. 

Image credit: R4vi via Flickr