Review: Murder Inn
By Luna Di Landro
Howard Voland and Keith McGregor’s Murder Inn establishes itself as your classic comic murder mystery, a perfect watch for the spooky season. The play debuted on April 28th, 2000 at Off the Wall Theatre in Monroe, Washington, and has since been frequently staged in community theatres across the United States and the UK. While originally set in eighteenth-century New England, co-directors Josh Brooks and Juliet Hepworth chose to set Sixth Side Theatre’s production slightly closer to home in Scotland. The play follows a group of tourists and their tour-guide, as a severe storm halts their journey, leading to a rather uncomfortable detour to The Barnsley Inn. Supposedly haunted by a knife-throwing poltergeist named Marco, the inn emerges in chaos when a power outage hits and the guests start turning up with fatal stab wounds. The survivors are left to solve the mystery before they become the next victim.
Set and Props Assistant Hachi Farrington successfully cultivated an atmosphere of domesticity, leaving the audience oblivious as to what was to come
The stage itself was familiar to the audience; it consisted of an appropriately vintage sofa, an armchair, and a smaller table around which we assumed the discussions about ‘whodunit’ would take place. Set and Props Assistant Hachi Farrington successfully cultivated an atmosphere of domesticity, leaving the audience oblivious as to what was to come.
Characterisation was generally done well, with distinct highlights. Dan Morris’ portrayal of Lawrence Currier was particularly striking; his stage presence and delivery of speech conveyed Lawrence’s arrogant persona perfectly, taking up space both physically and metaphorically. One of the most comical has to have been Martha Talbot, played by Aurora Bowman, whose sarcastic, passive-aggressive delivery highlighted the idiocy of the other guests, accentuating the overall humour. Similarly, Elsa Ogston McDowell did well in presenting Agnes Tate as the infuriatingly picky aunt, leaving both audience and cast members equally frustrated.
However, while individual performances stood out, the comedy and suspense overall was lacking several times throughout. On occasion, the jokes and banter landed poorly due to an inappropriately slow pace and delivery. The majority of the exposition and the final scenes felt as though they dragged, resulting in an absence of the anticipation so crucial to the plot of any murder mystery. Lighting Designer and Operator William Dinnie was successful in creating tension through the use of frequent blackouts, leaving the audience completely unawares. Unfortunately, however, during one of the earlier scenes of discovering the flying knives the blackout failed, revealing a stage crew member placing the knife in the table. This negated any suspension created in the prior scene, which was a shame.
Nothing got as much of a reaction as the joke pertaining to Nigel Farage’s acceptance of bribery – that landed very well indeed
Following the first murder in Act 2, the pace seems to pick up and becomes more engaging for the audience. The slapstick comedy from here on was quite effective. Notable was the fight between Jake Talbot (Tom Oakes) and Agnes, in which his shirt was ripped off. This received plentiful gasps and giggles, even more so when Carolyn Pickett (Abi Hensman) kissed his cheek. Lawrence and Muriel’s re-entry looking disheveled (evidently some sexual innuendo) was also very funny. However, nothing got as much of a reaction as the joke pertaining to Nigel Farage’s acceptance of bribery – that landed very well indeed.
The ending of the production felt simultaneously cathartic and anticlimactic. On the one hand, the performances from Todd Currier (Will Bradley) and later Carloyn succeeded in creating tension in the build up to the big reveal. The chase of Todd off stage was a welcome break from the relatively stagnant position the characters had been in up until that point. Equally, Hensman’s display of agitation, revenge and fear all at once was captivating, as she revealed her motives. That being said, the very final scenes felt somewhat repetitive, the mundanity of the closing conversations weighing down the excitement of the reveal.
One of the weakest points across the board was a vague lack of enthusiasm
Overall, the production was successful in conveying the characteristics of a comic murder mystery, making good use of comedic timing, physical comedy and lighting to build suspense. A tighter focus on building characterisation would not have gone amiss, as well as a bit more animation. One of the weakest points across the board was a vague lack of enthusiasm, and so while some characters were very convincing, the overall effect was not. Nonetheless, it was an enjoyable experience that certainly got some laughs and gasps out of me and the rest of the audience!
Image: Sixth Side Theatre via Instagram

