Guilt, implication and nausea – Donna Tartt’s The Secret History

By Isobel Atkins

In the very first sentence of The Secret History, Donna Tartt lets the reader in on a secret: ‘The snow in the mountains was melting and Bunny had been dead for several weeks before we came to understand the gravity of our situation’. Instantly, you are implicated. From the opening you are, unwillingly, an accomplice to the crime, plotting alongside the characters for the next 300 pages. Tartt’s decision to delay the murder so far into the novel has the effect of escalating the reader’s dreadful anticipation of its occurrence to the point where one is desperate for it to finally happen. This implicates the reader not only in their knowledge of the crime and its plot, but even subtly causes them to emotionally invest in its completion. Tartt manipulates you so cleverly that you don’t even realise you are eagerly awaiting Bunny’s death. From the book’s detached beginning, there is no turning away.

What is yet more masterful is how Tartt, having instantaneously spilled the beans (by subverting the reader’s expectations of having to earn the secrets promised in her tantalising title) still leaves us continually guessing. How will these events unfold? And, more importantly, what other atrocities will be revealed on the way? The reader’s inside knowledge drives the tension which defines the novel’s first half. This is exacerbated as Richard, the narrator, discovers more about the activities of his new cult-like group of friends, revealed in compounding layers of abomination.

However, when Bunny’s death finally does take place, the tension and expectation has risen to such a point that its actual occurrence feels somewhat underwhelming. Tartt’s choice to refrain from explicitly describing the murder deprives the reader of the catharsis which she has been building towards. This is explicitly addressed as Richard narrates that he is ‘sorry […] to present such a sketchy and disappointing exegesis of what is in fact the central part of my story’. Further noting, ‘even the most garrulous and shameless of murderers are shy about recounting their crimes’. This jolts the reader abruptly out of the suspenseful crescendo; the tension suddenly subsides. What we are left with is that unshakeable churning of our stomachs. Sticky sickness and discomfort pervade Tartt’s consequent description of the different ways each of the characters spiral and decline in the wake of their sins. What sees us through to the end of the book is this nausea and despair, as we witness the characters cope as best they can with the aftermath.

One poignant culmination of this nausea is found at Bunny’s funeral, described through Richard’s guilt-ridden perspective. After naming and exploring relatively few characters throughout the book up to this point, Tartt suddenly introduces an overwhelming number of names and faces, many of which are described as nauseatingly reminiscent of the features of the deceased, briefly introduced before fading back into the whirlwind of grievers. The effect of this seems to induce a motion sickness both in Richard and in the reader. The dilution of the main characters into this sea of people in this way further dissipates the power held by their cult, and the tension is displaced with overwhelming panic and guilt. Tartt’s repeated references to water when describing the crowd of people at the funeral further this idea of motion sickness, from the effort of ‘swimming through the bobbling crowd’ and melancholy of the ‘rain-spattered window’ to the ridiculous, ghastly onslaught of ‘complicated questions about surfing’. This imposition of light-hearted conversation into the grim internal feeling of the characters returns us to the sense of whirling, queasy disorientation. The nausea only worsens as the book nears its conclusion. Talking to the beautiful Camilla late in the book, Richard is suddenly overcome with ‘a fierce, nearly irresistible desire to seize Camilla by her bruised wrist, twist her arm behind her back until she cried out, throw her on my bed’. Here the reader begins to feel distinctly uneasy viewing the story’s events through Richard’s morally deteriorating perspective, augmenting the novel’s inescapable discomfort.

In this way, The Secret History charts a perceptible shift from the raising of tension through cultish behaviour and suspense of a foretold murder in which the reader is implicated, towards a lasting impression of discomfort and nausea which defines the aftermath of Bunny’s murder. This odd cocktail of tension and sickness is what will stay with you long after the last page.

Image Credit: Jean-Léon Gérôme (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)