Former student receives apology from University after transphobia controversy

By and

A former Durham University student who made national news in a row over transphobia has received a letter of apology from Durham University’s Department of Philosophy. 

claimed he had been subject to “harassment and bullying” by the department in the wake of the controversy, which had centred around a post he shared on Twitter in 2018. This initial complaint was not upheld, but upon review he was issued with a letter of apology regarding the handling of the complaint.

The letter to Sofocleous read: “The Philosophy Department could have dealt with [your] initial complaint in a more appropriate and timely manner. I am sorry that you feel we fell short in your case. 

“I am writing to apologise for that on behalf of the department and assure you that in future we will make efforts to process complaints quicker.”

The letter was sent via the Student Conduct Office. In a statement to Palatinate, Sofocleous questioned “how honest and heartfelt any apology is if it’s communicated via a third party”. He also said he had been subject to “victim blaming”. 

In future we will make efforts to process complaints quicker

Durham University Department of Philosophy

The initial controversy was based on a retweet by Sofocleous in 2018 while he was a philosophy postgraduate, that read: ‘“RT [retweet] if women don’t have penises” linked to an article on the same subject in The Spectator.

In the following months, Sofocleous was removed from his position as assistant editor of Durham’s Philosophy journal, Critique, dismissed as General Editor of The Bubble, and, under mounting pressure, resigned his position as President-Elect of Humanist Students. His resignation statement, which defended his actions, can be read here

Sofocleous’s actions attracted widespread controversy within Durham as well as nationally. 

The tweet received backlash from Chris Ward, former Chair of LGBT Humanists, for being “horrific” and “transphobic.”

Sofocleous garnered support from Toby Young, British Journalist and former Director of the New Schools Network, who tweeted Sofocleous’ replacement as editor of Critique, asking: “Shouldn’t you be encouraging debate about important issues rather than stifling it?”

Sofocleous’s actions attracted widespread controversy within Durham as well as nationally

After his dismissal as assistant editor of Critique and General Editor of The Bubble, Sofocleous filed a complaint to Durham’s Students’ Union regarding his “unfair treatment”.

In a letter addressed to Sofocleous from the Students’ Union, Sofocleous’ dismissal from the institutions was deemed “procedurally incorrect”, “unfair and undemocratic”.

The letter continued to say “You are entitled to hold and express these views.

“The Societies were also entitled to react to your free speech with their own expression of free speech, including a vote of no confidence.”

The letter added, “This is, in my view, an indication of a healthy democratic environment – as long as both sides are heard. This did not happen in your case.”

The SU also posted an apology on their website, which said: “After investigation, Durham SU wishes to apologise to for the process used to remove him from the roles of Deputy Editor of The Bubble and Assistant Editor of the Philosophy Society Journal, Critique.”

5 thoughts on “Former student receives apology from University after transphobia controversy

  • But women DON’T have penises! This is not an opinion or a belief, but a fact, known universally to anyone who is not mentally retarded or a raving lunatic. So can idiots please stop punishing innocent people for stating facts, now? There is no such thing as ‘transphobia’ either, but there is such a thing as realism, so let’s all remember that. And stick to it.

    Reply
    • whilst it’s absolutely true that women don’t have penises, it’s also true that some women do have penises. all the best xx

      Reply
      • speak of the raving lunatics and one shall appear, insisting that “some women have penises”.

        silly lunatic.

        Reply
  • Obviously women don’t have penises. But there is such a thing is transphobia. We do need to protect those in our society that are different. But pretending that humans don’t have the same two sexes as all mammals is absurd and doesn’t protect anyone.

    Reply
  • I agree with you on this – I have a few online friends who are trans and they agree that trans women are male and trans men are female and don’t find it ‘transphobic’ to acknowledge that. I have an offer from Durham to start in September but I’m really worried I won’t like the ‘woke’ culture there. Are you a current student? Is it difficult to find friends who are pro- free speech / have centrist or centre-left views / are gender critical? I live in the North East and I’m starting to think I might just stay out of the whole university social scene and stick with existing friends because everyone says Durham uni is full of posh people who are obsessed with identity politics and I’m worried that they might be right and that I’m at risk of saying the wrong thing and having my life ruined.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Floriana Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.