Durham University responds to Robert Jenrick’s accusations of “anti-white discrimination”

By Hugh Ludford and Finn Watton

In an article published by the Daily Mail, Reform UK MP Robert Jenrick has accused a new Durham University access scheme of being “a blatant case of anti-white discrimination.” Durham University has said “This story is untrue. We do not discriminate or make contextual offers based on ethnicity.”

The scheme in question, the Asian Access programme, will support Asian students, specifically those from disadvantaged areas of the UK, looking to attend Durham University. It will work alongside a number of other access programmes.

Durham University has said “This story is untrue. We do not discriminate or make contextual offers based on ethnicity.”

The scheme includes taster sessions during a pilot summer school for a limited number of subjects, including Law, Biosciences, Finance, Politics, and Psychology. 

Upon completion, the scheme guarantees an alternative offer to Durham University, which is not exclusive to the Asian Access programme but is available through similar schemes for students of all ethnicities. The University says the alternative offer “is typically two A-level grades below the standard entry requirements”.

Speaking to the Daily Mail, Jenrick said of the scheme “This is a blatant case of anti-white discrimination.”

He said “It is bizarre that Durham University think it’s sensible to lower the grades for British Asian students when they already outperform their white British counterparts.”

“University admissions must treat students equally and stop trying to socially engineer outcomes by creating a two-tier system.”

Jenrick told the Mail that a Reform UK government would “end this nonsense” and “make our universities meritocratic once again.”

Robert Jenrick was sacked from the Conservative Party in January after plans for his defection to Reform UK reached Kemi Badenoch. He has since joined Reform UK and is currently their treasury spokesperson.

Jenrick labelled it “bizarre” for the University to “think it’s sensible to lower the grades for British Asian students when they already outperform their white British counterparts.”

As well as the requirements above, the scheme has academic requirements around studying subjects relevant to their prospective course, and of GCSE results.

“Mitigating circumstances” will be considered, including for care experience, would-be first-generation scholars, cases of estrangement, and those entitled to free school meals. 

Consideration of mitigating circumstances is intended “to identify students with merit and potential who are currently underrepresented in higher education and at Durham University.”

This scheme is in line with Durham University’s Access and Participation Plan (APP) put in place this academic year. Notably, the APP seeks to increase the percentage of Durham University students of Asian heritage to 7.5% by 2028/29.

In the APP, the University highlighted their aim to increase Asian representation, noting that, “[i]n 2021/22, 6.5% of students admitted to undergraduate study were of Asian heritage” compared to 11.1% at Oxford, 17% at Cambridge, 38.6% at UCL, and 25.6% at Warwick. 

Furthermore, the University noted that the largest percentage gap between applications and enrolments has been among Asian applicants. 

As noted above, the same alternative offer is also awarded upon the completion of three other Durham University Widening Access and Participation programmes for students from disadvantaged backgrounds. 

These are: Destination Durham, which is for students in the North East; Space to Explore Potential, which is for students of black heritage; and the Sutton Trust Summer School Programme, which is open to all students who have only had access to state-funded education. 

The same alternative offer is also awarded upon the completion of three other Durham University Widening Access and Participation programmes for students from disadvantaged backgrounds

A Durham University spokesperson has told Palatinate:

“This story is untrue. We do not discriminate or make contextual offers based on ethnicity.

“We encourage applications from all talented students with the potential to succeed at Durham University, irrespective of background.

“Our admissions decisions are fair and based on published entry criteria. 

“We agreed with the Office for Students as part of our published access and participation plan that we would increase our numbers of students who are underrepresented at Durham through a range of targeted intervention schemes and a range of financial support.

“We offer several access programmes of academic study to support underrepresented students to apply and prepare for university and thrive while they are here.

“Students must meet published criteria to apply successfully, including demonstrating high academic achievement and potential, and come from neighbourhoods with low progression rates for university.

“Contextual offers, which are standard practice in the higher education sector and shown to be effective in supporting underrepresented students to access university, are made to all eligible students who complete successfully their programme of academic study.”

Image: Rose Stacy, Palatinate