Durham Professor weighs in on Pornhub lawsuit

By Ivan Deverick

Content warning: this article mentions sexual assault and other themes which some readers may find upsetting.

Clare McGlynn, Professor of Law at Durham University, criticised global media company Aylo, owner of website Pornhub, for continuing to host harmful content despite their implementation of new verification practices. Professor McGlynn is an expert on the legal regulation of pornography and forms of online abuse. She has advised governing bodies and is currently Deputy Head of the Faculty of Social Sciences and Health at Durham University. 

A recent business article in The Sunday Times titled ‘Pornhub lawsuits expose ‘sordid underbelly’ of financial services’ quoted her, saying that Aylo and, more specifically, Pornhub have changed how they operate, putting in place content controls that have been better than some “rogue” sites as well as X. The claim stems from a history of lawsuits against Pornhub regarding illicit material uploaded to the site without subsequent removal. At one point, the article states, the site deleted more than 80 per cent of its videos and introduced new verification methods for people who posted and starred in content to ensure consent. Professor McGlynn said that Ireland, where the company is located, is reviewing its pornography laws, and has started realising how the prevalence of “sexually violent, racist and misogynistic content” impacts society. She suggested in a comment to Palatinate that Aylo could simply stop algorithmically promoting content of that kind. Regardless, she said, content they allow on the site does violate its own terms and conditions, such as the rule that they do not accept harmful forms of incest. A change she would like to see in their terms and conditions is them banning content where the person is asleep at the beginning of a sexual encounter. ‘This is rape’, she said. She mentioned research at Durham University which found that one in eight titles on the three most popular pornographic websites describe sexual violence. ‘This research, together with my work on legal regulation, revealed to me just how disturbing so much of the mainstream content of online Porn is.’

“This research, together with my work on legal regulation, revealed to me just how disturbing so much of the mainstream content of online Porn is.”

Professor CLare McGlynn

The widely publicised case at Cornell University regarding accusations of student gang-rape relates to this, as “it is mainstream Porn that is the underpinning of the attitudes that lead to the behaviours like the men at Cornell. “For students, the promotion of sleep Porn, disregarding women’s consent, and practices such as strangulation, have considerable adverse impacts. ‘To women, if you’re feeling uncomfortable about engaging in sexual practices, you’re not alone. You do not have to put up with it.”

Image Credit: Palatinate