‘Are we losing our creative voices to robots?’ The loss of human voice in modern artwork.

By Helena Rise

The topic of AI posing a threat to human existence has been a popular point of discussion in recent months, and rightfully so. Statistics from Anthropic and other research facilities have warned us of the 10% chance that AI could kill humans within the next decade. So, it is no wonder that this news, and public fears surrounding AI, have spread so quickly. 

What most people don’t realise, however, are the ways in which AI has already rapidly infiltrated our lives from not just from a technological stance, but from a creative one too. Ten years might seem a way off right now, but AI’s ability to diminish the human voice is an immediate issue, particularly within the artistic field. Before we lose our lives to artificial intelligence, we are first condemned to losing our own voices. 

Take, for example, the world’s first AI ‘artist,’ Ai-Da. Named after Ada Lovelace, the 19th-century pioneer of computer programming, Ai-Da is a humanoid robot with the ability to produce world-class artwork that sell for hundreds of thousands of pounds. Devised by Aidan Meller at Oxford in 2019, this so-called ‘artist’ creates ‘her’ pieces based upon a checklist of provided stimuli (such as colours and subject context). With camera vision and robotic limbs, she produces works that appear, at least to the human eye, as though a real person created them. 

Her most renowned piece is her painting of Alan Turing titled ‘A.I. God,’ which sold for over one million US dollars in 2024 at the Sotheby’s digital art auction. Having dedicated this to the founder of computer science, Ai-Da provides a visual demonstration, and perhaps a glorification, of the overwhelmingly rapid evolution of computer technology and its abilities. 

Ai-Da provides […] perhaps a glorification of the overwhelmingly rapid evolution of computer technology and its abilities

This piece, however, was only the beginning of her artistic career. Ai-Da has gone on to produce multiple pieces, including a portrait of King Charles III titled ‘Algorithm King,’ which was unveiled at the 2025 ‘AI for Good’ global summit. 

Ai-da’s existence begs the question: ‘Are we being indoctrinated into accepting there is normality in the use of AI to create art?’ Personally, I believe that applauding AI produced artwork and giving it such a substantial platform like this a serious cause for concern.

The Oxford Dictionary itself states the very definition of art to be ‘the expression or application of humancreative skill and imagination,’ something which Ai-Da does not have despite Meller’s attempts to prove otherwise. In an interview with BBC Future, Meller claims she has personal opinions and artistic inspiration, explaining that Ai-Da’s work is heavily inspired by the cubist movement. But, objectively, Ai-Da cannot ‘feel’ as we humans do. She cannot think introspectively about things. She does not know what something ‘is like.’ She is merely a technological system composed of computer algorithms and generative AI models, acting upon those tasks that she is programmed to perform.

Though the pieces she produces appear human, the intention behind them is fundamentally different. This poses the major ethical issue as to whether she should be allowed to produce artwork at all. If the definition of art requires a creative imagination, how can we consider a robot without the facilities to imagine to be an artist? I believe this is what truly matters in the artistic world, and promoting humanoid artwork only feeds into an unfeeling tool with the capacity to take over our very own methods of self-expression. 

With artworks like Ai-Da’s becoming so successful, it is undoubtable that artificial intelligence will continue to infringe upon the human art scene, whether that be through AI image generation or robotic Picasso’s like Ai-Da. Artists who have dedicated careers and livelihoods to their work are vulnerable to being undervalued, lost amongst the works of soulless artificial intelligence.

If the definition of art requires a creative imagination, how can we consider a robot without the facilities to imagine to be an artist?

But what I find most frightening of all is that robots like Ai-Da have the ability to seemingly generate the human experience, despite their lack thereof. These new ‘artists’ may not feel, but we humans do. There is power in creating art, and we need to be very careful with who we give that power to. It makes me wonder if we are headed towards a world where we are susceptible to being entirely manipulated by robots. Ai-Da seems to suggest so, quite blatantly in the title of her first work: artificial intelligence is the new God. The human voice is a valuable tool within the artistic world, and it’s imperative that we take Ai-Da’s existence as a warning before we cross the point of no return.

Image: Leemurz via Wikimedia Commons