Am I fictional? Muriel Spark’s ‘The Comforters’
By Emilia Birch
Muriel Spark’s debut novel The Comforters closely examines the literary trope of the ‘neurotic young woman’ in a creepy and puzzling work of metafiction. Amid its many wild and varied plotlines, it is consistently concerned with voice. Caroline Rose, Spark’s brilliant but troubled protagonist, is tormented by a chorus of voices and the tapping of typewriter keys, which eerily repeat her thoughts and movements. While the people Caroline confides in either try to admit her to a rest home or dismiss her as just one of her boyfriend Laurence’s ‘beautiful, neurotic women’, she gradually becomes convinced that she is the main character in a novel being written by what she calls the ‘Typewriter Ghost’. The novel never offers a clear answer as to whether Caroline really is hallucinating, or if the Ghost is real, if the voice is Spark’s, or Caroline’s, or just another layer of voices which make up the narrative. It is at turns a mystery, a ghost story, and a deceptively humorous insight into contemporary attitudes to mental health.
The novel begins with Caroline away on a religious retreat, while Laurence, staying in his grandmother’s cottage in Sussex, has just made the discovery that the elderly Louisa is involved in something sinister. Caroline escapes home after a few days of suffering the constant companionship of the repulsive Mrs Hogg, catering manager of St. Philumena’s centre, while the charming but incurably nosy Laurence discovers a cache of diamonds hidden in a loaf of bread. From there, the narrative moves swiftly and bizarrely from religion to devil worship, bigamy to blackmail, until its final, ending twist; the plot is admittedly ridiculous, yet told with a great deal of humour, subtlety, and sympathy.
It is little wonder that when the Ghost insists that she is fictional, Caroline chooses to believe this
Spark came up with the idea for The Comforters after suffering herself from a series of medication-induced hallucinations. The depiction of Caroline first hearing the voices is vividly described and effectively captures her terror. Desperate to find where the noises are coming from, she ransacks her flat before fleeing to a friend’s house, still followed by the tapping of the keys and the chorus of mingling voices. “I am not mad. I’m not mad.” Caroline tells herself desperately. “I am being haunted, I am not haunting myself.” Caroline is a recent convert to Catholicism, and so her initial attempts to label what is happening to her range from being possessed by the devil, to a nervous breakdown. But the nature of her hallucinations is so specific; the cool, detached voice of the Ghost narrates her own thoughts back to her, word-perfect, third-person, past tense.
It’s understandable that Caroline eventually becomes convinced that everyone around her, Laurence, her magic-obsessed friend the Baron, Mrs Hogg, are all just fictional characters in a novel the Ghost is writing. This theory brings Caroline a great deal of comfort, especially as most of the people in her social circle decide she is just another young woman with a nervous disorder. For beneath its wit and light-heartedness, The Comforters does provide an insightful, intelligent commentary on contemporary attitudes to women’s mental health. It is perhaps telling that when Caroline first admits to the Baron that she is hearing things, she admits both to downplaying what has happened and also feeling the need to play a ‘false role’ in order for him to take her seriously. And, while it is often coupled with humour, it is a little alarming that Caroline’s experiences are repeatedly dismissed as just being ‘neuroticism’, a term which seems to have been used for a range of conditions and experiences which were in fact far more complex and should have been taken much more seriously.
The Comforters closely examines the literary trope of the ‘neurotic young woman’
Caroline’s experience thus becomes incredibly isolating, with Laurence preoccupied with the ridiculous mystery of his grandmother’s diamond smuggling. The passages of hallucinations persist throughout the text, but they fade into the background as Caroline is forced to accept her situation, and in doing so reflects on what the people around her are also hiding. “Is the world a lunatic asylum then?” She asks the Baron. “Are we all courteous maniacs discreetly making allowances for everyone else’s derangement?” It is little wonder that when the Ghost insists that she is fictional, Caroline chooses to believe this over the other options: admitting that she is insane, or submitting to being regarded as Laurence’s fragile, nervous girlfriend.
The role of voice in The Comforters is complex and subtle, turning its premise of ‘hearing voices’ into a witty, but ultimately troubling depiction of the treatment of mental health.
Image Credit: Edvard Much (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

